I think the most alarming thing about this is the 72 hour claim. Are we expected to be pacified or reassured that the government will be able to respond within 3 days if an unexpected catastrophic event occurred - an attack on our water supply systems (or destruction of a couple of reservoirs) would lead to weeks or months of outages. It will take MPs a month to conclude the debate on a proposal for a consultation on a response.
Recently the largest supermarket chain in the country here saw suspicious activities on their servers and had to shut down nearly everything to contain the hack. Online delivery was stopped immediately, empty shelves soon followed. It took them a week to get the logistics back in order.
That was an unsuccessful attack that paralysed nearly 40% of supermarkets here. No need to use the stockpiles just yet, but a good indicator that it doesn’t take much for shelves to go empty for a bit.
I don’t think it’s about a widescale attack with catastrophic loss of infrastructure.
You’re right, in those situations 72 hours isn’t going to help much.
A more realistic scenario might be power failures across a region caused by extreme weather. Or something like the Spain and Portugal blackout last year.
Last year during a storm a tree came down and blocked our road for 36 hours. They had over 60 across the area to deal with. We’ve had 6-8 hour powercuts caused by a bird because the power infrastructure here is 80 years old and fragile.
Nearby, a fault with a valve meant 5000 people didn’t have running water for a week. They were able to provide bottled water but they had to prioritise vulnerable people so this just means you don’t need to be top of the list.
I think the most alarming thing about this is the 72 hour claim. Are we expected to be pacified or reassured that the government will be able to respond within 3 days if an unexpected catastrophic event occurred - an attack on our water supply systems (or destruction of a couple of reservoirs) would lead to weeks or months of outages. It will take MPs a month to conclude the debate on a proposal for a consultation on a response.
Recently the largest supermarket chain in the country here saw suspicious activities on their servers and had to shut down nearly everything to contain the hack. Online delivery was stopped immediately, empty shelves soon followed. It took them a week to get the logistics back in order.
That was an unsuccessful attack that paralysed nearly 40% of supermarkets here. No need to use the stockpiles just yet, but a good indicator that it doesn’t take much for shelves to go empty for a bit.
I don’t think it’s about a widescale attack with catastrophic loss of infrastructure.
You’re right, in those situations 72 hours isn’t going to help much.
A more realistic scenario might be power failures across a region caused by extreme weather. Or something like the Spain and Portugal blackout last year.
Last year during a storm a tree came down and blocked our road for 36 hours. They had over 60 across the area to deal with. We’ve had 6-8 hour powercuts caused by a bird because the power infrastructure here is 80 years old and fragile.
Nearby, a fault with a valve meant 5000 people didn’t have running water for a week. They were able to provide bottled water but they had to prioritise vulnerable people so this just means you don’t need to be top of the list.
Our modern society is incredibly fragile.