My initial response to your comment was mostly out of shock of what you said. Congratulations! You are the first person to actually shock me on this platform. It’s morning for me now and I’ve had a good night’s sleep. I’ve had a moment to properly rebuttal. Your contrived bullshit. Please enjoy your own evisceration.
Your entire argument is a collection of historical distortions, straw men, and logical contradictions. Let’s address them individually.
First paragraph: What exactly is your point? Yes, historical atrocities and political oppression can create the conditions in which extremist organizations emerge. That’s hardly a revelation. But explaining the historical circumstances that contributed to the creation of Hamas does not establish that Hamas is justified in its actions. Causation is not justification. By your logic, virtually every extremist organization in history could excuse its atrocities by pointing to something that happened before its formation. That’s an intellectually bankrupt argument.
Second paragraph: At no point did I suggest that any Jewish person deserved to die, nor does my argument remotely imply that. I explicitly oppose the murder of innocent people, regardless of their ethnicity, religion, or nationality. Suggesting otherwise is either a spectacular failure of reading comprehension or a deliberate misrepresentation of what I said.
Your historical assertion about Muslims and antisemitism is equally ridiculous. Antisemitism in Muslim-majority societies has a long and complicated history that predates both World War II and the establishment of Israel. Relations between Muslim and Jewish communities varied considerably across centuries and geographical regions. Pretending antisemitism was essentially invented after World War II, or manufactured after 1967, is historical revisionism. Furthermore, Muslim empires conducted their own wars of conquest, religious persecution, and expansion. The historical record is considerably more complicated than the sanitized narrative you’re attempting to present.
Third paragraph: I never claimed the Muslim Brotherhood engaged in random violence against Jews. That’s an argument you invented because apparently responding to what I actually said was too difficult. Political and ideological violence is rarely random. That doesn’t make it justified. Understanding the motivations behind an organization is not the same thing as endorsing its conduct.
Your fourth paragraph is where your argument completely falls apart. You accuse me of supposedly suggesting that some Jews deserved to die, then explicitly declare that Hamas is entirely justified in everything it has done, including murdering civilians. Do you understand the contradiction? You are defending the very principle you’re accusing me of advocating: that civilians can be legitimate targets because of their nationality, political circumstances, or perceived collective responsibility.
You don’t get to condemn collective punishment in one breath and endorse the murder of civilians in the next. That isn’t a coherent moral position. It’s hypocrisy.
Finally, your last paragraph and accompanying links don’t establish what you seem to think they establish. You are conflating public opinion, political attitudes, participation in military operations, and collective responsibility as though they are interchangeable concepts. They aren’t. A poll showing support for a particular policy does not establish that every member of a population is responsible for it, much less that civilians are legitimate targets for violence. Nor does it establish that every Israeli supports genocide or has participated in military operations. Your sources do not demonstrate the conclusions you’re drawing from them.
And this brings us to the fundamental problem with your entire position: you seem incapable of distinguishing between explaining why an organization exists, understanding the grievances that motivate its supporters, and morally justifying its actions.
Those are three entirely different things.
You can acknowledge Palestinian suffering, condemn Israeli atrocities, recognize the historical circumstances that contributed to the emergence of Hamas, and still unequivocally condemn Hamas for murdering civilians. There is absolutely no contradiction in doing so.
The only contradiction here is yours. You have constructed an argument in which violence against civilians is reprehensible when you dislike the perpetrator, but entirely justified when you approve of the political cause.
I suggest you seriously reconsider the moral and intellectual foundations of that position before lecturing anyone else about genocide, historical context, or human rights.
My initial response to your comment was mostly out of shock of what you said. Congratulations! You are the first person to actually shock me on this platform. It’s morning for me now and I’ve had a good night’s sleep. I’ve had a moment to properly rebuttal. Your contrived bullshit. Please enjoy your own evisceration.
Your entire argument is a collection of historical distortions, straw men, and logical contradictions. Let’s address them individually.
First paragraph: What exactly is your point? Yes, historical atrocities and political oppression can create the conditions in which extremist organizations emerge. That’s hardly a revelation. But explaining the historical circumstances that contributed to the creation of Hamas does not establish that Hamas is justified in its actions. Causation is not justification. By your logic, virtually every extremist organization in history could excuse its atrocities by pointing to something that happened before its formation. That’s an intellectually bankrupt argument.
Second paragraph: At no point did I suggest that any Jewish person deserved to die, nor does my argument remotely imply that. I explicitly oppose the murder of innocent people, regardless of their ethnicity, religion, or nationality. Suggesting otherwise is either a spectacular failure of reading comprehension or a deliberate misrepresentation of what I said.
Your historical assertion about Muslims and antisemitism is equally ridiculous. Antisemitism in Muslim-majority societies has a long and complicated history that predates both World War II and the establishment of Israel. Relations between Muslim and Jewish communities varied considerably across centuries and geographical regions. Pretending antisemitism was essentially invented after World War II, or manufactured after 1967, is historical revisionism. Furthermore, Muslim empires conducted their own wars of conquest, religious persecution, and expansion. The historical record is considerably more complicated than the sanitized narrative you’re attempting to present.
Third paragraph: I never claimed the Muslim Brotherhood engaged in random violence against Jews. That’s an argument you invented because apparently responding to what I actually said was too difficult. Political and ideological violence is rarely random. That doesn’t make it justified. Understanding the motivations behind an organization is not the same thing as endorsing its conduct.
Your fourth paragraph is where your argument completely falls apart. You accuse me of supposedly suggesting that some Jews deserved to die, then explicitly declare that Hamas is entirely justified in everything it has done, including murdering civilians. Do you understand the contradiction? You are defending the very principle you’re accusing me of advocating: that civilians can be legitimate targets because of their nationality, political circumstances, or perceived collective responsibility.
You don’t get to condemn collective punishment in one breath and endorse the murder of civilians in the next. That isn’t a coherent moral position. It’s hypocrisy.
Finally, your last paragraph and accompanying links don’t establish what you seem to think they establish. You are conflating public opinion, political attitudes, participation in military operations, and collective responsibility as though they are interchangeable concepts. They aren’t. A poll showing support for a particular policy does not establish that every member of a population is responsible for it, much less that civilians are legitimate targets for violence. Nor does it establish that every Israeli supports genocide or has participated in military operations. Your sources do not demonstrate the conclusions you’re drawing from them.
And this brings us to the fundamental problem with your entire position: you seem incapable of distinguishing between explaining why an organization exists, understanding the grievances that motivate its supporters, and morally justifying its actions.
Those are three entirely different things.
You can acknowledge Palestinian suffering, condemn Israeli atrocities, recognize the historical circumstances that contributed to the emergence of Hamas, and still unequivocally condemn Hamas for murdering civilians. There is absolutely no contradiction in doing so.
The only contradiction here is yours. You have constructed an argument in which violence against civilians is reprehensible when you dislike the perpetrator, but entirely justified when you approve of the political cause.
I suggest you seriously reconsider the moral and intellectual foundations of that position before lecturing anyone else about genocide, historical context, or human rights.