Then what’s the point of this post? Because it sounds like “Buddhism bad because there’s at least one bad faction that can be identified in its entire history”
The post doesn’t say that Buddhism or Christianity are bad. Westerners are just more familiar with the fucked up parts of Christian history than the fucked up parts of Buddhist history. As a result Buddhism is sort of portrayed as this peaceful religion whose adherents do no wrong, which doesn’t survive contact with actually reading about history.
Interesting you say Westerners when my experience with the “Stop saying all religions are bad, Buddhists never did anything wrong” people are typically Asian.
Can they typically read Chinese history books? Because the person portrayed in the OP can’t. I think it’s pretty clearly implying someone from a different cultural background who is unfamiliar with Buddhist history, like most Westerners whose deepest thought about Buddhism is usually along the lines of ‘peaceful monk’.
People in the west who also know nothing about buddhism, also tend to do a lot of hand-waving and virtue signaling about western misconceptions of buddhism.
Do a lot of misconceptions about buddhism exist in the west? Yes, of course. Is every notion of buddhism entertained in the west a misconception? Not by a longshot. And unless you know which is which, it’s kind of chauvinistic to go around declaring every statement made about buddhism to be “orientalist.”
There are people in the west, both scholars and practitioners, who understand buddhism on a much deeper level than the average normie who only knows about a few miscontextualized concepts that were appropriated by the “self-help” industry. As well as on a much deeper level than the smugly dismissive not-your-average-normie who responds to every mention of buddhism with an overplayed and poorly thought-out accusation of romanticized orientalism.
This is a really bizarre set of assumptions to make based on ‘I’m pretty sure the meme is just saying the average westerner doesn’t know much about Buddhist history’, which is just true if you aren’t a religion nerd or a history nerd. Good luck with all that, though
It sounds to me like the people making assumptions are the ones trying to depict buddhism as violent merely because they can point to one or two extremist factions, while ignoring the entire rest of the history and context of it and the fact that those extremist factions are aberrations and not the norm.
We all know of edgelords who think “anti-religion” is a virtue to signal, but let’s be honest with ourselves and admit that it’s just another form of bigotry, ignorance, and hate.
All religion are bad but some are worse if you go deep and learn real rules of each. Atheism should not exist as it should default in this modern world
You say that as someone who seems to have very little understanding of “real” buddhism, and you’re making assumptions based on a biased opinion and preconceived notions about religion as a whole.
“if you go deep” anything can be bad, including atheism. If your goal is fault-finding, you’ll always be successful.
If your goal is finding something that can be beneficial to people, society, or the world, you can find those things too.
If the good outweighs the bad, then getting rid of it would cause more harm than good.
And again I state that it’s chauvinistic of you to decide for other people what they can or can’t hold as religious beliefs and practices.
Enforced atheism is a form of thought-policing. When someone asks “what if there is more to life than this material world that meets the eye and is observable by specialized equipment,” suddenly you need to go issuing fines for thought crime.
Banning religion is a treacherous and unhealthy thing to do for a society. Better to focus on the harms that particular sects and people cause, and punish those, and shape policy around preventing those harms. Not nuking the whole thing.
The point is that western atheists will present Christianity and Islam as uniquely bad or wrong, and that claim something like Buddhism is somehow more acceptable because no one has committed atrocities in its name.
That is, of course a false, orientalized, view of Buddhism. A genocide is being carried out in its name now. Pointing that out isn’t to say all Buddhists are bad, that would also be orientalist. Rather, it’s being pointed out to say that you can use any ideology to justify whatever action you’d like.
Okay you can think that, but if you try to ban religion we’re going to have problems. Because you’d be no better than any other religious faction that tries to assert its own supremacy.
And my whole point is that you can’t just point to a few examples of extremist factions who commit atrocities in the name of religions, and use that as evidence to claim the whole religion is bad.
Because it’s absolutizing, overgeneralizing, chauvinistic, and culturally imperialistic to make a claim like that.
What matters isn’t whether it’s abrahamic, vedic, or even animistic in origin. That’s beside the point entirely.
And my whole point is that you can’t just point to a few examples of extremist factions who commit atrocities in the name of religions, and use that as evidence to claim the whole religion is bad.
Because it’s absolutizing, overgeneralizing, chauvinistic, and culturally imperialistic to make a claim like that.
Okay, I don’t see why other people aren’t getting that. Like they’re accusing me of feeling superior simply because I said they shouldn’t do those things? When in reality the people who do the things I’m admonishing against are the ones who feel superior.
My entire position here can be boiled down to “maybe we should respect people’s autonomy and not make assumptions based on incomplete information and cherrypicked views of history.”
This isn’t a crusade. If anything it’s a counter-crusade. Because the crusaders are the ones going around saying we need to eliminate religion. Those are the only ones in this thread trying to force their worldviews on others and calling for the destruction of worldviews that don’t align with their own.
Literally all I’ve been saying this whole time is that you can’t do that because that’s wrong and if you try then you’re the one in the wrong.
If that’s a crusade to you then whatever, I won’t waste any more time on you. Have fun killing me in your anti-religious pogroms or whatever.
The point of the post is a reaction to people who say “Stop saying all religions are bad and lead people to violence. I’m Buddhist and we never did anything wrong!”
They aren’t? That’s why we don’t say all Muslims are the same as the Taliban or all Christians the same as MAGA.
Then what’s the point of this post? Because it sounds like “Buddhism bad because there’s at least one bad faction that can be identified in its entire history”
The post doesn’t say that Buddhism or Christianity are bad. Westerners are just more familiar with the fucked up parts of Christian history than the fucked up parts of Buddhist history. As a result Buddhism is sort of portrayed as this peaceful religion whose adherents do no wrong, which doesn’t survive contact with actually reading about history.
Interesting you say Westerners when my experience with the “Stop saying all religions are bad, Buddhists never did anything wrong” people are typically Asian.
Can they typically read Chinese history books? Because the person portrayed in the OP can’t. I think it’s pretty clearly implying someone from a different cultural background who is unfamiliar with Buddhist history, like most Westerners whose deepest thought about Buddhism is usually along the lines of ‘peaceful monk’.
People in the west who also know nothing about buddhism, also tend to do a lot of hand-waving and virtue signaling about western misconceptions of buddhism.
Do a lot of misconceptions about buddhism exist in the west? Yes, of course. Is every notion of buddhism entertained in the west a misconception? Not by a longshot. And unless you know which is which, it’s kind of chauvinistic to go around declaring every statement made about buddhism to be “orientalist.”
There are people in the west, both scholars and practitioners, who understand buddhism on a much deeper level than the average normie who only knows about a few miscontextualized concepts that were appropriated by the “self-help” industry. As well as on a much deeper level than the smugly dismissive not-your-average-normie who responds to every mention of buddhism with an overplayed and poorly thought-out accusation of romanticized orientalism.
This is a really bizarre set of assumptions to make based on ‘I’m pretty sure the meme is just saying the average westerner doesn’t know much about Buddhist history’, which is just true if you aren’t a religion nerd or a history nerd. Good luck with all that, though
What part of what I said was an assumption?
It sounds to me like the people making assumptions are the ones trying to depict buddhism as violent merely because they can point to one or two extremist factions, while ignoring the entire rest of the history and context of it and the fact that those extremist factions are aberrations and not the norm.
We all know of edgelords who think “anti-religion” is a virtue to signal, but let’s be honest with ourselves and admit that it’s just another form of bigotry, ignorance, and hate.
If you don’t want to engage in good faith I can’t make you, have a day 👍
All religion are bad but some are worse if you go deep and learn real rules of each. Atheism should not exist as it should default in this modern world
You say that as someone who seems to have very little understanding of “real” buddhism, and you’re making assumptions based on a biased opinion and preconceived notions about religion as a whole.
“if you go deep” anything can be bad, including atheism. If your goal is fault-finding, you’ll always be successful.
If your goal is finding something that can be beneficial to people, society, or the world, you can find those things too.
If the good outweighs the bad, then getting rid of it would cause more harm than good.
And again I state that it’s chauvinistic of you to decide for other people what they can or can’t hold as religious beliefs and practices.
Enforced atheism is a form of thought-policing. When someone asks “what if there is more to life than this material world that meets the eye and is observable by specialized equipment,” suddenly you need to go issuing fines for thought crime.
Banning religion is a treacherous and unhealthy thing to do for a society. Better to focus on the harms that particular sects and people cause, and punish those, and shape policy around preventing those harms. Not nuking the whole thing.
the point is that the most people believe buddhism as a whole has always been a-ok and that’s simply false.
What is “buddhism as a whole” then? In your words, how would you describe that?
The point is that western atheists will present Christianity and Islam as uniquely bad or wrong, and that claim something like Buddhism is somehow more acceptable because no one has committed atrocities in its name.
That is, of course a false, orientalized, view of Buddhism. A genocide is being carried out in its name now. Pointing that out isn’t to say all Buddhists are bad, that would also be orientalist. Rather, it’s being pointed out to say that you can use any ideology to justify whatever action you’d like.
Well, I’m a western atheist and I think that all religions, without exceptions, is shit.
Okay you can think that, but if you try to ban religion we’re going to have problems. Because you’d be no better than any other religious faction that tries to assert its own supremacy.
Yeah, of course. The only thing I’d do if I had the power to do it is banning religions from taking important religions.
We don’t want another 1990.
And my whole point is that you can’t just point to a few examples of extremist factions who commit atrocities in the name of religions, and use that as evidence to claim the whole religion is bad.
Because it’s absolutizing, overgeneralizing, chauvinistic, and culturally imperialistic to make a claim like that.
What matters isn’t whether it’s abrahamic, vedic, or even animistic in origin. That’s beside the point entirely.
I agree
Okay, I don’t see why other people aren’t getting that. Like they’re accusing me of feeling superior simply because I said they shouldn’t do those things? When in reality the people who do the things I’m admonishing against are the ones who feel superior.
My entire position here can be boiled down to “maybe we should respect people’s autonomy and not make assumptions based on incomplete information and cherrypicked views of history.”
I don’t understand why that’s so controversial.
everyone gets it just fine, you’re just on a crusade in this thread.
This isn’t a crusade. If anything it’s a counter-crusade. Because the crusaders are the ones going around saying we need to eliminate religion. Those are the only ones in this thread trying to force their worldviews on others and calling for the destruction of worldviews that don’t align with their own.
Literally all I’ve been saying this whole time is that you can’t do that because that’s wrong and if you try then you’re the one in the wrong.
If that’s a crusade to you then whatever, I won’t waste any more time on you. Have fun killing me in your anti-religious pogroms or whatever.
The point of the post is a reaction to people who say “Stop saying all religions are bad and lead people to violence. I’m Buddhist and we never did anything wrong!”