• wonderingwanderer@sopuli.xyz
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    4 days ago

    Yeah, I shouldn’t get so worked up about it, but I view it as dangerous rhetoric so it wouldn’t feel right to stand aside and let it fester.

    All that’s needed is for people to discuss calmly and objectively. In time, we can all reach a consensus.

    I don’t think this is the type of thing where we need a consensus. People can live their own lives as long as they’re not harming others. There doesn’t need to be consensus on the best cuisines or the best language for poetry. These are cultural phenomena, and as such, diversity is a good thing.

    No one knows anything for sure. We don’t know if there’s a god, we don’t know if our lives have purpose beyond our own satisfaction. We don’t know what happens when we die, or before we were born for that matter.

    And there’s the rub - religion claims to have the answers to these questions.

    Buddhism doesn’t claim to know the answers to any of those things. It’ll just take the student by the hand and encourage them to inquire and gain insight into the nature of reality.

    It doesn’t give answers to anything, except occasionally as pedagogical tools which are later discarded once their lessons are learned.

    This is what I mean by saying westerners tend to project western notions of religion into eastern religions where those western notions don’t fit. “This fundamental deceit at the core of all religion is what makes it toxic” is a valuation statement you’re making based on the western religions you’re more familiar with.

    Do shitty people who pretend to teach buddhism exist? Yes, and they’re a recognized problem among credible buddhist teachers. You really shouldn’t discredit the credible ones based on the actions of the scammers and cultists.

    • MouldyCat@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      3 days ago

      I view it as dangerous rhetoric so it wouldn’t feel right to stand aside and let it fester.

      I know what you mean, I feel the same when I see someone making excuses for religion!

      I don’t think this is the type of thing where we need a consensus

      So I think we do actually. You see, in this modern world where we are all connected and empowered, I think it’s increasingly important for individuals to be able to think critically and objectively, and to be able to identify and discard magical thinking.

      It doesn’t matter if some particular person’s magical thinking produces outcomes which are nice or harmless according to your or my judgement. Magical thinking is inherently unstable, and it can lead people to commit atrocities.

      You’re right that I don’t know much about buddhism. I do want to say that I’m uneasy about the “east” vs “west” division you’re making though, I don’t think it’s accurate and it feels divisive. I’m most familiar with what I call the Jewish religions i.e. Judaism and its offshoots: the Jesus cults, and the Mohammed cults. None of these are really from the west, Judaism obviously originated in the area we now call Palestine, which is also where the Christ figure lived and died. Mohammed lived and died to the west of that, in Arabia, but still, not really in “the West”. I know I know, the Romans spread Christianity through Europe, but that’s only one subgroup of that Jewish family of religions.

      My point is that I don’t find east vs west a helpful distinction. Something more precise might be Vedic religions vs all the others. I don’t know if that’s an actual term, but Buddhism is one of the many religions which hold the Vedic texts sacred, isn’t it? Like Hinduism, which was never really the single monolithic religion it’s presented as outside of India.

      So to get back on track, what I have heard about Buddhism is interesting. I worked with a guy who called himself a Buddhist, I remember him saying that Buddhists don’t believe in a creator god, nor that karma is a system designed to punish or reward people, rather it’s simply a “mechanism” whereby the path you take through reincarnation is guided by the state of your soul - these are my words not his, he said something to that effect, I don’t remember exactly what he said now, he didn’t use the word soul.

      Anyway I found it an interesting viewpoint. I’ve thought myself that if you believe our conscious experience is a physical phenomenon that is caused entirely by our brains, then reincarnation would seem to be inevitable, because something similar enough to my brain is bound to exist again at some other time outside of my current life. Put another way, if you have infinite time, then anything which is possible will happen an infinite number of times.

      Another thing which pops into my head about Buddhism is a story I remember reading some time ago (probably over 10 years ago) where the Dalai Lama said that if science were to disprove reincarnation or something else about his beliefs, then he would have to accept that and change his view. I thought that was a good position for a leader of a religion to hold, although someone later said that he only said that because he knew science would never be able to prove or disprove such a thing.

      So if you’re telling me that Buddhism doesn’t have any books of revealed truths which dictate how you should live or which pass judgement on others for not living (or loving) in the ordained way, and doesn’t have some hierarchy of people who have some magical communication channel with supernatural entities that normal people don’t have, and also doesn’t depend on magical thinking at all, then maybe it is different. I’m certainly open to that possibility.

      • wonderingwanderer@sopuli.xyz
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        3 days ago

        I know what you mean, I feel the same when I see someone making excuses for religion!

        I’ve never attempted to excuse the actions of particular religious people or sects who cause harm. And I don’t need to make excuses for ones who don’t.

        I think it’s increasingly important for individuals to be able to think critically and objectively,

        Is that what people in this thread are doing? Because it seems like you’re the only one even attempting to engage with this rationally. Everyone else just discards or ignores every point that I make, and then they default to some cookie-cutter arguments for why they need to enforce their worldview on others and how it’s actually okay when they do it because they gave themselves a special exception to the exact thing they’re criticizing other people for, which is the feelings of supremacy thay many (not all) religious people hold.

        Which is, again, not something that I excused, so focusing on that instead of the content of what I’m saying is a strawman.

        and to be able to identify and discard magical thinking.

        Nothing I’ve argued in this entire thread has been “magical thinking.”

        It doesn’t matter if some particular person’s magical thinking produces outcomes which are nice or harmless according to your or my judgement. Magical thinking is inherently unstable, and it can lead people to commit atrocities.

        It’s not magical thinking. The benefits of buddhism are backed by science. You’re making so many assumptions, and even when I point them out you keep making them.

        I do want to say that I’m uneasy about the “east” vs “west” division you’re making though, I don’t think it’s accurate and it feels divisive.

        Buddhism originated in the eastern part of the globe. Even in modern scholarship “East” and “West” are clean shorthands commonly used to categorize different philosophies and religions. In an academic context, the meaning will be understood.

        Yeah, Abrahamic religions originated in the Middle East (or more accurately West Asia), yet they’re mostly included in the history of western civilizations and thus categorized as “West”

        “Eastern” schools of thought can refer to ideas from Arabia and Persia (and sometimes even Byzantium), but typically it refers distinctively to South Asian and East Asian schools of thought.

        That’s not really divisive, it’s just descriptive. If someone tries to claim Buddhism originated in the West, they’d be wrong. Unless you’re speaking from East Asia and referring to the Indian subcontinent as “the West,” which happens in a famous koan about Bodhidharma.

        But that doesn’t change how those terms are used in scholarship, because it’s a useful distinction.

        Something more precise might be Vedic religions vs all the others. I don’t know if that’s an actual term, but Buddhism is one of the many religions which hold the Vedic texts sacred, isn’t it?

        Buddhism has Vedic origins in the same way Christianity has Judaic origins, but calling Buddhism a “Vedic religion” would be just as incorrect or more as calling Christianity a “Jewish religion.”

        Buddhism does not hold the Vedic texts as sacred, and for the most part doesn’t even use them. A buddhist scholar might read them for historical or dialectical reasons, but they don’t really have a place in buddhist practice or canon.

        There are many ideas buddhism inherits from the Vedic tradition, but many of them are redefined or reinterpreted in the Buddhist canon, and some are rejected entirely. The most famous distinction is in how the Vedas propose an essential selfhood, whereas Buddhism says there is no essential selfhood.

        Which is an idea that influenced post-modernism, a mostly-western (as that distinction does begin to break down by the 20th century) school of thought at the root of the atheist movement that people in this thread are such staunch proponents of.

        Like Hinduism, which was never really the single monolithic religion it’s presented as outside of India.

        That is correct. Buddhism on the other hand is technically one religion, as it traces back to the same founder. However it’s also a very diverse tradition with different schools of thought and practice lineages that emerged in different regions and at different times.

        Unlike western religions, Buddhism often cross-pollinated/integrated with the existing cultures, and so many regional variants today preserve elements of the indigenous/animist folk traditions of the areas they sprung up. Because it wasn’t about conquest or forced conversions like we see in the history of western religions. The closest comparison we have in the west is a few symbols from pagan holidays, like “christmas” trees and easter eggs.

        Your coworker was mostly correct about buddhism not having deities (except for in specific cases where they assimilated the local pantheon, but even in those cases they’re viewed as useful symbols rather than mysterious space ghosts with actual existence).

        He was also correct about karma being viewed as a mechanism rather than a contrived system of punishments. Like how if you punch a wall, the wall punches back with equal and opposite force. But on a cosmic scale.

        if you believe our conscious experience is a physical phenomenon that is caused entirely by our brains, then reincarnation would seem to be inevitable,

        That part is a misconception though, it sounds like you’re referring to Maya which is a Hindu concept. That’s the thing that says “the world is illusion.” Buddhism doesn’t claim that, and in fact it asserts that the world of sensory phenomena is real and should be treated as such.

        Also, not all buddhists believe in reincarnation, especially in modern times. Most buddhists believe in science, and even the ones who believe in an afterlife often do so in a sort of agnostic skepticism, like “maybe, maybe not, won’t know till we get there. Better to live here and now while we can.”

        So if you’re telling me that Buddhism doesn’t have any books of revealed truths which dictate how you should live or which pass judgement on others for not living (or loving) in the ordained way,

        Buddhist texts are not “revealed texts” in the way many religions claim their texts to be. There are some regional variants that have similar concepts, but it’s not a part of the overall buddhist canon and most buddhist schools of thought don’t rely on that sort of thing. In fact one of the main points of Zen Buddhism is that you should reject external authorities and fixed ideas.

        [Edit to add: also, buddhism isn’t about passing judgement. It’s more about radical acceptance. That doesn’t mean tolerating harms, but accepting reality as it is. And that includes the fact that other people live their lives in their own ways, and that won’t always align with one’s own ways, and that’s okay.

        There is also the Vinaya, which is a monastic code, and only applies to monks. It’s a set of rules intended to foster a healthy/harmonious community and prevent abuses or other friction that can occur when hundreds of people live together.

        Thirdly, there are the precepts, which practitioners are encouraged to follow. But these are more “guidelines for virtuous living” intended to maintain inner and outer harmony, rather than “rules/commandments for moral conduct” like we see in western religions. Most of the precepts boil down to “Do no harm, not even to yourself.” And doing wrong, such as hurting someone, is also viewed as harming oneself.]

        and doesn’t have some hierarchy of people who have some magical communication channel with supernatural entities that normal people don’t have,

        There is lineage in buddhism, and that described the teacher→student relationships as they’re passed down from generation to generation. But it’s not about supernatural communications. It’s how they certify/recognize the authenticity of various teachers, and also distinguishes between different schools of thought and practices that can have a range of subtle distinctions (like Rinzai Zen or Soto Zen, for instance).

        and also doesn’t depend on magical thinking at all, then maybe it is different.

        The only magical thinking you’ll find is in preserved elements from regional indigenous traditions that existed before buddhism, and the reason those are preserved is because buddhism explicitly did not come to conquer and enforce one worldview over another. It only brought enlightenment, which is for everybody.

        And it’s not mystical, it’s just being fully present here and now, perceiving accurately, empty of preconceived notions, and not driven by the incessant urges to seek pleasure and run from pain (nor to seek pain and run from pleasure, either).