• metermatic26@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    1 day ago

    Ukraine has been able to cut off Crimea for a very long time now, but chose this moment to strike.

    The fact that they struck just as Putin is about to meet Xi and Trump is offcourse deeply humiliating for Putin, but the strike also going to create a huge dilemma for Russia.

    Russia can’t maintain Crimea without the bridge, but Putin cannot afford the humiliating defeat of losing it either. That means Russia will have to supply Crimea through highly exposed and dangerous routes.

    I’m guessing it will force Russia to divert even more resources to the south and suffer inevitable losses trying to maintain its présence in Crimea. And this comes right before winter, while Russia is still desperately trying to capture Kostiantynivka (also at staggering costs) and right as Ukraine is pushing into the vulnerable areas of the front line further to the north.

    • Taldan@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      17 hours ago

      Ukraine has been able to cut off Crimea for a very long time now, but chose this moment to strike.

      That’s a bold claim. Do you have sufficient evidence to back that up?

      It seems extremely unlikely. Why would Ukraine sit on such a strategically important attack? They could lose the opportunity at any moment

      If they could have done it when Trump was heavily pressuring Ukraine before the election, why wouldn’t they have done so? It was a much better moment for such a big victory

      • metermatic26@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        2 hours ago

        ‘Evidence’? Sure, I’ll just call Ukraine’s military planners and ask 😁 Look, I’m just an arm chair general who likes to speculate.

        Still, why would it be a bold claim? It’s been known for years that Ukraine has the military capabilities to block the Kerch bridge and possibly bring it down altogether. The timing was very deliberate and they’ve clearly been planning the strikes for a very long time. And there’s plenty of well mentioned reasons not to bomb the bridge.

        For one, actually doing so is a pretty big escalation. Its one of the few options the Ukrainians actually have to escalate and to pressure the Russians and its one that is sure to invite further attacks on civilians.

        Another is that Ukraine lacks the military means to retake Crimea and hold it. They have been really succesful at bleeding the Russian military, to the point that Russia can no longer use Crimea for large scale air or naval operations, but they can’t actually push the Russians out of Crimea.

        So the strikes were also going to be motivated more by politics and strategy rather than tactical advantages.