• LincolnsDogFido@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    13
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    8 hours ago

    Then maybe they should have disposed of it in a decommissioned salt mine deep underground a long time ago instead of waiting 20 years for it to degrade to the point of being dangerous to handle. That’s the military’s problem to handle, not the millions of people that would be affected by this detonation.

    If soldiers happen to die in a self detonation trying to safely remove and dispose of it, then so be it. They signed up for the military knowing that their lives would potentially be cut short. I say this knowing I have a few friends in the military, but that’s the reality. Then if someone is killed in the line of duty disposing of this stuff, the commanding officer in charge of it’s storage and maintenance should be court martialed and punished for negligence resulting in the needless loss of life for the soldiers under their command. Period.

    • JasonDJ@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      6 hours ago

      It was never meant to be disposed. It was stored for usage in ordinance, but there was some sort of a moisture leak (going off memory from one of the articles I read on this…may be mistaken), which lead to it becoming unstable.

      This was discovered during routine inspections.

      It’s also much, much, more dangerous to try to transport it than it is to blow it up in-place. It’s that unstable.

      What they are doing is really the only option. It sucks, but at least they are evacuating the area ahead of time and adding mass and watering the grounds to try to contain the plume to the base as much as possible.

      Also remember that explosives are used for civil engineering and excavation, not just war.

      It seems like the media is trying to stir outrage as much as possible with this. Not that there shouldn’t be outrage, but it is misdirected. Army should have had better plans for storage/moisture prevention (clearly there was a failure somewhere here). Should not have stored so much in one location. Should have had more frequent inspections (as I understand, it was annual). Etc.

      But now that they are at this point, controlled explosion is the only option, and all they can do is damage control.

      Hopefully something is learned from this.

      A fair civilian comparison would be the Washington Bridge debacle in Providence, RI…it was discovered during a routine inspection that the westbound bridge was in danger of eminent collapse, which of course could have been a huge disaster (it’s a pretty busy bridge).

      The bigger story is all the failures and corruption that lead up to that discovery, but the media and the state don’t discuss that. Instead they just stir the pot about the traffic. Don’t want to let the rubes know how close they were to winning the shittiest lottery because of corruption and bribes.

      • LincolnsDogFido@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        7
        ·
        6 hours ago

        The danger involved in detonation covers large swathes of Iowa and surrounding states with lead contamination, affecting as I said millions with lead contamination of commercial crops, personal gardens, soil, waterways, and the water table.

        It’s easy to see this as a inescapable outcome, when you aren’t in the projected area of fallout.

        • jh34ghu43gu@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          4
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          4 hours ago

          Going back to your original comment

          If soldiers happen to die in a self detonation trying to safely remove and dispose of it, then so be it.

          Where exactly is it going to self detonate trying to move it that is safer than where it’s at now? If it detonates on the road that is far worse for everyone in the surrounding area because now there is no mass above it and the watered grounds around it.

          The compound detonates if it falls six inches.

          That’s so insane to try and move probably miles to a safer location. Jason did not mention that the urgency for detonating it now is that cold weather increases its instability. There’s a real potential that it just explodes when no one is expecting it. And again, that’s worse for everyone in the surrounding area because now there is no warning.

          Yes, something went wrong, someone(s) should be blamed and probably lose their job or serve time. But everything I’ve seen all point to this bomb blowing up soon; and it can either be randomly by itself or at a set time where people nearby at least have some ability to reduce their exposure.

          It’s easy to see it as an inescapable outcome because that really is where we are at. It shouldn’t have gotten to this point, but it did, and now that’s the choices we have. Unless you have a better one; I am only thinking about this with 4hrs of sleep in the last ~40. Imma go take a nap.

          • LincolnsDogFido@lemmy.zip
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            3
            ·
            2 hours ago

            It’s easy to see it as an inescapable outcome because that really is where we are at.

            That’s categorically false. The Army and EPA have provided a credible explanation for why this cache has degraded and why it’s critically sensitive, but in the time since then, they have not provided risk assessments that demonstrate that alternative methods are infeasible or carry more risk. Which is why a fedral appeals court has temporarily blocked the EPA permit authorizing the detonation. Their plan was convenient for the military because it’s over in an instant and they can stop thinking about it. They were hoping that 5 days was short enough notice that people wouldn’t be able to organize in time to stop it and force them to properly dispose of the danger using careful planning and time.

            As is, they could prepare for a potential intentional detonation while simultaneously exploring other options. It would have the same relative outcome if it somehow managed to self-detonate. And a warning to the public should have no basis in this argument because they gave surrounding states worth of civilians just 5 DAYS notice to stay inside. That’s not nearly enough time to mitigate the consequences of their proposed method and that’s IF we were to ignore the ecological systems affected by lead contamination and focus only on local affects.

            The stay in your houses advice is such a line of bullshit too. Houses aren’t hermetically sealed. Houses need ventilation and lead particles won’t be captured by normal HVAC systems in most cases. I’m weird and buy MERV 11 filters and change them every 3 months like you’re supposed to, but most people barely change them unless they happen to accidentally think about it. Even then, my HVAC system wouldn’t capture all of the lead containing particles–let alone someone that changes their air filter once or twice a year with a cheap bottom of the barrel fiberglass filter.

        • plyth@feddit.org
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          4 hours ago

          affecting as I said millions with lead contamination

          Americans became too intelligent.

    • Obviouslywrong@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      6 hours ago

      I would say they prioritized disposing of the old chemical weapons first and they’re mostly done with that now but it was the correct choice because those were much bigger deal.