ESH. Kid shouldn’t have done it, but also the lady shouldn’t let the cat outside

I’ll take things that never happened for 200$

You can tell the people in here thinking it’s ok to retaliate like that are people that live alone with cats or in their parents basement with cats. I have cats and children. Y’all this isn’t the way to go about this.

As a parent, if my kid did that, I’d likely side with the neighbour. I would put it (very loosely) in the category of “natural consequence” punishments.

It fits the crime, it discourages the crime, it forces empathy with the cat, and it does no real harm.