• 0 Posts
  • 13 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 10th, 2023

help-circle

  • HugoNebula@alien.topBtoBooks@metacritics.zoneFilm vs Book
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    “…the question here is, seriously, what is the point in making subpar, incomplete, movies…”

    I get this isn’t your literal question, but nobody (or almost nobody) sets out to make a bad movie, whether original or an adaptation. To answer your more specific question, it comes down to essentiality or practicality: Tom Bombadil—as many Lord of the Rings readers will tell you—is hardly germane to the plot of the book (I find he kills the story just as it—finally—gets going), and easily removable from a film adaptation, where length is key; as to Jurassic Parks’s raptor pen, that will have been as a result of special effects technology coming up against the budget, where the nascent CGI technology and practical effects of the time would have been far too expensive to justify a scene which is, as we see, largely inessential to the plot.








  • It’s the author’s tenth novel, so a maturation of style mid-book seems unlikely; and, again, if OP is worried they’re accidentally reading a book meant for younger readers, that’s a strange and largely inconsequential worry to be having, especially in public. There are plenty (given Sturgeon’s Law applying equally) of YA and even children’s books worth an adult’s time and attention, if they can just get over themselves.




  • You may do better asking on /r/stephenking, but here’s how I answered this question on that sub some time ago.

    Having been a Constant Reader for 40+ years, I would group King’s periods into smaller defined groups, as follows:

    New and Hungry Writer (original ideas/original approach): Carrie to The Stand.

    Booze and Cocaine, Part I (The Good Books): The Dead Zone to Pet Sematary.

    Booze and Cocaine, Part II (Some Good, Some Bad, Some Ugly Books): The Talisman to The Tommyknockers.

    Getting Clean and Sober (and rediscovering how to write without drugs, and with wife Tabitha’s help): The Dark Half to Needful Things.

    Clean and Sober (with a 50/50 success rate): Gerald’s Game to The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon.

    Hit and Run (Books Written After a Near-Death Experience): Dreamcatcher to The Dark Tower.

    Period of Public Acceptance (Post-2003 Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American Letters): The Colorado Kid to End of Watch.

    Working Retirement (Books Quickly Written, and Hardly Revised): Gwendy’s Button Box to Fairy Tale and on.

    Hope that helps!