They should have the players who received medical treatment taken off for 5 minutes as well , might cut down the amount of fake injuries.
Just fuck off leave the game alone
Stop ruining the game with idiotic new rules!
More subjectivity for the refs to interpret differently every week
This is a good idea to attempt to change the culture in football. Punishments for several pretty shitty things are too lax, so players aren’t really disincentivized from doing them. This could help.
But, of course, it depends on good implementation…
The amount of fuckwits that cry arse for red cards now for any sort of contact post slide takle, it’s only fair we start to weed out the shite red card decisions.
Red cards used to be used for brutal damaging leg breakers. These days you get Curtis Jones getting reds cos his foot slipped over the top of the ball and made contact with an apponent at 10mph.
You ruined the game yourselves.
Sin-bins?
Never thought a hockey term would be used in football.
Just make it two yellows equals a sin bin. A third is a sending off. This will only add to the confusion.
If they use this for a non-dangerous last man foul for a penalty then I agree, it would be a bit more fair than the current double whammy of a sending off and a penalty.
This is not good.
I think a better orange card rule is to force sub the player who commited the offence. If no subs available then you go to 10 men. But if you have subs, it means the team loses that player, but aren’t down to 10 men.
I love this idea
Could be good to prevent cheating if done right
Can we just sin bin all referees in operation for 10 centuries and replace them with some that can actually follow the current rules?
I actually don’t mind this idea.
I’m Irish and I watch a lot of Gaelic football and the black card is the exact equivalent of this. They use it really well I believe, where cynical fouls as in stopping attacks and hard tackles that aren’t necessarily reds.
The difference is in Gaelic football it is 15 v 15 and with 4 extra players on the field teams won’t hide back and defend as much as they likely would here.
I would say it deserves a trial, as in next season’s Carabao Cup where the stakes are lower we could see how it plays out.