I read some of Mao’s works and informed me on MLM(the Gonzalo line not MZT) and my question Is why do ML’s don’t like MLM? and why PPW Is not universal like MLM’s claim? My opinion Is that PPW even viewed as just the three phases Mao speaks about adapted to one material condition Is not enough to say it Is universal because the theory that those three phases are universal also needs to form from material reality and so Is just idealist but it still doesn’t convince me and It might come from me not being educated enough on the matter so let me understand.

  • Calfpupa [she/her]@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    14 days ago

    What is the full quote of Lenin about “economic suicide”? I can’t find it easily.

    Fwiw this description is nothing like the maoists I’ve worked with. They practice HM, they are not dogmatic and are very bottom-up.

    • pcalau12i@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      edit-2
      14 days ago

      What is the full quote of Lenin about “economic suicide”? I can’t find it easily.

      Comes from “The Tax in Kind”: “What is to be done? One way is to try to prohibit entirely, to put the lock on all development of private, non-state exchange, i.e., trade, i.e., capitalism, which is inevitable with millions of small producers. But such a policy would be foolish and suicidal for the party that tried to apply it. It would be foolish because it is economically impossible. It would be suicidal because the party that tried to apply it would meet with inevitable disaster. Let us admit it: some Communists have sinned ‘in thought, word and deed’ by adopting just such a policy. We shall try to rectify these mistakes, and this must be done without fail, otherwise things will come to a very sorry state.”

      He says something similar in “Left-wing Communism”: “The abolition of classes means, not merely ousting the landowners and the capitalists — that is something we accomplished with comparative ease; it also means abolishing the small commodity producers, and they cannot be ousted, or crushed; we must learn to live with them.”

      Of course, who says it doesn’t particularly matter since it’s not gospel, what matters are the reasons it is said, the substance behind it, which is that socialism is built upon socialized production, which is laid autonomously by the development of the forces of production, not by state decree. People often use “capitalist” to refer to anyone who engages in any sort of finance, but often in these older texts “capitalist” specifically meant the “big bourgeoisie” that already operated very large, highly socialized enterprises that could be expropriated for the nation, while other terms like petty bourgeoisie and small commodity producer is used for everyone else.

      How you deal with the “capitalists” (big bourgeoisie) is “comparatively easy” because you can just expropriate their already national-scale enterprises as the basis for your national-scale enterprises. But how you deal with the small producer is much more complicated, because obviously a small producer can acquire capitalistic, and not socialistic, interests, but also there is no material basis to expropriate them, so you have to somehow square that circle, and it is something that was never fully worked out and is something socialist countries today are still trying to work out.

      Although, it wasn’t unexpected. In Hilferding’s Finance Capital in the last chapter he talks about this, how a socialist revolution that builds a socialist state but still possesses a large portion of its economy dominated by small enterprise will find itself in a long-term struggle to maintain the dominance of the socialist system while having to contain the contradictions from the vestigial capitalist elements, which could last for a long, long, long time.

      I’d highly recommend Bukharin’s “Anarchy and Scientific Communism” where he discusses how what separates anarchism from Marxism is that Marxists don’t want to build a brand new society “out of a void” but want to expropriate the foundations already created by finance capital.

      Fwiw this description is nothing like the maoists I’ve worked with. They practice HM, they are not dogmatic and are very bottom-up.

      It’s a framework for a scientific theory of socioeconomic development, it’s not really a “practice,” unless you just mean a “practice” as in using it in your analysis. If so, if you’ve really talked to tons of Maoists who genuinely have a historical materialist analysis, then how did they justify to you that MLs are “revisionist” just for upholding the orthodox Marxist view of socioeconomic development? What argument did they use to justify their claim that not making all private enterprise illegal is a form of “revisionism”?