i think it definitely looks like the revolutionary force compared to the alternative, but do you not think maybe that’s simply rethoric? i mean a cop who now rules a gang doesn’t sound like a very welcoming revolutionary leader, specially since at least what i’ve read from him seems to attack the “oligarchy” rather than a proper revolutionary discourse. and i say this because that’s something heard in a lot of latam countries from moderate lefts who are a bit anti imperialists. here in argentina the peronists’s rethoric is essentially the same, they denounce the “oligarch” instead of the bourgeois. i’ll watch the interview, though, and he makes me think of ibrahim traore, but unsure if he can sustain a proper state afterwards. anyway, i need to watch that interview, it definitely seems interesting and maybe i’m wrong, so just asking from ignorance.
The oligarchy is how we call the bourgeoisie in many places Latin America. It’s a particularity of the economic development of our region, most of our territories were colonies, with big plantations and a rich landowner class. In most of our countries there was never a bourgeois revolution, which created a big industrial proletariat. What happened is that our landowners became bourgeois after they integrated themselves with the global financial capital. So we have a characteristic of having a small urban proletariat, mostly working in low skill services, rather than having an industrial proletariat. Most of our economies rely on extractive processes, like mining, agricultural exports and oil.
But you are right in your point that being a popular leader doesn’t make one automatically socialist and revolutionary. If there isn’t a strategy of development of productive forces and socialization of means of production, it’s very likely that a revolution, even successful, will simply replace the players of the game with other players. And imperialism will take over in the end.
supongo que estaba pensando mas en el peronismo que otra cosa, porque he discutido mucho con peoronistas y ellos te hablan de oligarca. si les menciones a la burguesia se te cagan de risa como si les estuvieras contando un cuento chino. capaz es una peculiaridad del peronismo y en otros paises si tiene la connotacion que vos describis. puede ser eso porque ademas estos togas te hablan de que ellos no son ni capitalistas ni marxistas, son “tercera posicion” pero de izquierda o una verga asi. que falopeada dios mio.
edit: ah you’re the brazilian comrade. sorry, here’s the translated comment.
I suppose I was thinking more about Peronism than anything else, because I’ve argued with Peronists quite a bit, and they always talk about oligarchs. If you mention the bourgeoisie, they laugh in your face as if you were telling them some far-fetched story. Maybe that’s a peculiarity of Peronism, and in other countries the term does carry the connotation you described. That could be it, because these clowns also go on about how they’re neither capitalist nor Marxist, but rather third position, albeit left-wing or some bullshit like that. What a load of crap, Jesus Christ.
Peronism is a strange political camp, with some weird mix of left wing and right ideas, imbued with some nationalism which can become quite chauvinistic sometimes. We had a political camp like this, Varguismo and Trabalhismo, but it died after the 1964 dictatorship. I hope another actual revolutionary revolutionary camp can dispute the leadership of the working masses.
That said, I think Argentina shares this trait of rich landowner class turned into a bourgeois-oligarchic class. Brazil, Argentina and Mexico are the most industrialized countries of Latin America, even though we are way more underdeveloped than the West and now East Asia.
Obs: Como un buen brasileño, entiendo un poco de Español, pero principalmente para leer y escuchar. Soy péssimo hablando o escrebiendo. ¡Solidaridad, camarada!
i think it definitely looks like the revolutionary force compared to the alternative, but do you not think maybe that’s simply rethoric? i mean a cop who now rules a gang doesn’t sound like a very welcoming revolutionary leader, specially since at least what i’ve read from him seems to attack the “oligarchy” rather than a proper revolutionary discourse. and i say this because that’s something heard in a lot of latam countries from moderate lefts who are a bit anti imperialists. here in argentina the peronists’s rethoric is essentially the same, they denounce the “oligarch” instead of the bourgeois. i’ll watch the interview, though, and he makes me think of ibrahim traore, but unsure if he can sustain a proper state afterwards. anyway, i need to watch that interview, it definitely seems interesting and maybe i’m wrong, so just asking from ignorance.
The oligarchy is how we call the bourgeoisie in many places Latin America. It’s a particularity of the economic development of our region, most of our territories were colonies, with big plantations and a rich landowner class. In most of our countries there was never a bourgeois revolution, which created a big industrial proletariat. What happened is that our landowners became bourgeois after they integrated themselves with the global financial capital. So we have a characteristic of having a small urban proletariat, mostly working in low skill services, rather than having an industrial proletariat. Most of our economies rely on extractive processes, like mining, agricultural exports and oil.
But you are right in your point that being a popular leader doesn’t make one automatically socialist and revolutionary. If there isn’t a strategy of development of productive forces and socialization of means of production, it’s very likely that a revolution, even successful, will simply replace the players of the game with other players. And imperialism will take over in the end.
supongo que estaba pensando mas en el peronismo que otra cosa, porque he discutido mucho con peoronistas y ellos te hablan de oligarca. si les menciones a la burguesia se te cagan de risa como si les estuvieras contando un cuento chino. capaz es una peculiaridad del peronismo y en otros paises si tiene la connotacion que vos describis. puede ser eso porque ademas estos togas te hablan de que ellos no son ni capitalistas ni marxistas, son “tercera posicion” pero de izquierda o una verga asi. que falopeada dios mio.
edit: ah you’re the brazilian comrade. sorry, here’s the translated comment.
I suppose I was thinking more about Peronism than anything else, because I’ve argued with Peronists quite a bit, and they always talk about oligarchs. If you mention the bourgeoisie, they laugh in your face as if you were telling them some far-fetched story. Maybe that’s a peculiarity of Peronism, and in other countries the term does carry the connotation you described. That could be it, because these clowns also go on about how they’re neither capitalist nor Marxist, but rather third position, albeit left-wing or some bullshit like that. What a load of crap, Jesus Christ.
Peronism is a strange political camp, with some weird mix of left wing and right ideas, imbued with some nationalism which can become quite chauvinistic sometimes. We had a political camp like this, Varguismo and Trabalhismo, but it died after the 1964 dictatorship. I hope another actual revolutionary revolutionary camp can dispute the leadership of the working masses.
That said, I think Argentina shares this trait of rich landowner class turned into a bourgeois-oligarchic class. Brazil, Argentina and Mexico are the most industrialized countries of Latin America, even though we are way more underdeveloped than the West and now East Asia.
Obs: Como un buen brasileño, entiendo un poco de Español, pero principalmente para leer y escuchar. Soy péssimo hablando o escrebiendo. ¡Solidaridad, camarada!