The figure of 700,000 is entirely fabricated. The officially documented death toll is in the 70,000s. Those are confirmed deaths, and there are hundreds of thousands of people still missing, many of whom are likely buried beneath the enormous quantities of rubble that once constituted much of the Gaza Strip.
Israel does not inherently have a right to exist. This is a line that gets repeated constantly, but it is fundamentally meaningless. No country has an inherent right to exist simply because it is a country. The land itself doesn’t care what borders humanity draws across it or what names we assign to those territories. The United States doesn’t have an inherent right to exist either.
People, however, have the right to exist.
Hamas has committed horrific acts of violence throughout its existence, including since Israel became a country. By any reasonable definition, it is a terrorist organization. I have no interest in defending Hamas or excusing its atrocities. However, none of that changes the fundamental issue: the people currently responsible for carrying out what increasingly constitutes genocide are the Zionist leadership in power in Israel.
Genocide is never justified. Not under any circumstances, not in retaliation, not in the name of national security, and certainly not in the name of historical grievances.
People have a right to exist. Governments do not have an unlimited right to commit atrocities in the name of protecting their existence.
We shouldn’t downplay the suffering of any widespread murder, genocide, but I just want to bring proportional attention to another atrocity:
Trump, Musk, and all enabling Republicans are responsible for at least 600,000 deaths in just 1 year’s time by the gutting of USAID known to have massive repercussions globally, and dwarfing the civilian death toll in Gaza and Ukraine, combined.
This matters because I still see a lot of people espousing false equivalence both sides bullshit on the two parties, and the truth is that these deaths simply would not have occurred under a Kamala Harris presidency. Food for thought.
On a separate note: AIPAC is calling in their favor to their Senators you see people from Mark Kelly to Kirsten Gillibrand bending the knee for Schumer. Call your Senators and tell them you’ll support their primary candidate next cycle and that you won’t support any of their Presidential bids in the future if they don’t support Van Hollen.
I’ve been telling mine that if he votes for schumer I will make it my life’s mission to replace him. I’ll go door to door. I’m disabled and I have all the time in the world.
I think we need to distinguish between the consequences of government policy and what legally or conceptually constitutes genocide. Gutting USAID was an extraordinarily destructive policy decision, and I understand the argument that its consequences will be measured in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths. However, government policies that result in widespread death, even when those consequences are foreseeable, do not automatically constitute genocide. We could point to numerous examples of other countries making similarly destructive policy decisions with devastating consequences for civilian populations.
I also think there is a broader philosophical question here. At some point, we have to acknowledge that other countries bear responsibility for the welfare of their own populations. America cannot simultaneously be expected to police the world, finance the humanitarian needs of every struggling nation, and dictate how other governments conduct their affairs. That doesn’t mean we should abandon humanitarian assistance. Personally, I would have continued USAID funding precisely because the human consequences of eliminating it were so foreseeable. I would consider that the responsible and rational decision. Unfortunately, those qualities appear to be in rather short supply in the current administration.
Ultimately, I agree with your broader criticism of the administration and the devastating consequences of its decisions. I simply think we should be precise about the language we use and the responsibility we assign.
As for Israel and AIPAC, I don’t find any of this particularly surprising. Of course Israel wants American politicians who advance its interests. The problem is when foreign interests, through lobbying, political financing, and other forms of influence, become so deeply embedded in American politics that elected representatives appear more concerned with accommodating those interests than representing their own constituents. We’ve been watching that dynamic play out for years, and it deserves considerably more scrutiny than it receives.
The problem is when foreign interests, through lobbying, political financing, and other forms of influence, become so deeply embedded in American politics that elected representatives appear more concerned with accommodating those interests than representing their own constituents. We’ve been watching that dynamic play out for years, and it deserves considerably more scrutiny than it receives.
Foreign interests shouldn’t be embedded at all in American internal politics, regardless. Including America’s meddling in other nation’s elections.
But I don’t respectfully think we need to spit hairs over this, if one’s activism priority is indeed the humanitarian and well-being of civilians, notably children – independent of nation-state and independent of strict legal definitions.
At the end of the day, it’s evidence that elections matter and evidence that 600,000 people (and rising) would be alive all over the world if not for a policy decision of a particular administration from elsewhere — no different than the policy decision of enabling aid to Israel. Whether that’s for wars, or for equipment for that.
Sorry but I lean toward the left, and I don’t engage in this bootstrapian rhetoric of, “fend for yourselves” — especially within the purview of this discussion where we are often responsible as well for the regional instability made in the first place. If outside forces are responsible for the instability, then even more so there is a humanitarian endeavor ot make it better. But no different than the aspirations of JFK and the Peace Corps and an underlying principle of the left, those who have the capacity to help have the obligation to do so.
So let’s not lose sight of our values and goals, and not get in the weeds of the games we often see those Zionists themselves play equivocal semantic games of, “Well is it a conflict, or a war; is it a genocide, or is it just reasonable collateral damage?” — It’s preventable death of innocent human lives, be it USAID revocation or strikes on densely-populated urban areas of Gaza or Russia’s cruel strikes on sovereign Ukrainian hospitals and schools just the same.
No. It was founded in 1948 following what the Palestinian people call the Nakba. A forceful relocation of the indigenous people of the area to accommodate for the people moving in. That in and of itself was already an atrocity.
I see what you’re saying. I may have worded my original statement poorly. What I meant to convey is that Hamas did not emerge in a historical vacuum. Its emergence was shaped by decades of Israeli policies, occupation, displacement, and violence against the Palestinian population, long before Hamas was formally established in 1987.
Hamas grew out of the Palestinian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood, whose presence in Palestine dates back to the 1940s. The broader Muslim Brotherhood movement itself was founded in Egypt in 1928. In other words, the ideological and organizational foundations that eventually produced Hamas had existed for decades before the organization formally came into existence.
I would argue that Hamas was a foreseeable consequence of the historical conditions in which it emerged. That does not excuse its actions or justify attacks against civilians, but understanding the circumstances that produced the organization requires examining the decades of Palestinian displacement, occupation, repression, and violence that preceded its formation.
The point is that 1987 marks the formal establishment of Hamas, not the beginning of the historical circumstances, political grievances, or ideological movements that ultimately gave rise to it.
I would also point out that your logic means at least some Jews deserved the Holocaust which is generally understood to be a shitty thing to say. Muslims were not antisemitic for the vast majority of their history. This association only happened post WWII, incidentally this concept only breached mainstream society post 1967 to explain why so many muslim-majority countries “attacked” Israel.
This weird myth that is implied by your argument, that the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood randomly did violence against Jews for no reason, is counter to the rest of your argument, that you should take in the historical and material reasons for resistance groups like Hamas to exist and use violence.
To make my position clear, **not only is Hamas explicitly and entirely justified in all actions they have taken, including against ‘civilians’, they have been the least violent resistance group in history considering the conditions that lead to their creation."
My initial response to your comment was mostly out of shock of what you said. Congratulations! You are the first person to actually shock me on this platform. It’s morning for me now and I’ve had a good night’s sleep. I’ve had a moment to properly rebuttal. Your contrived bullshit. Please enjoy your own evisceration.
Your entire argument is a collection of historical distortions, straw men, and logical contradictions. Let’s address them individually.
First paragraph: What exactly is your point? Yes, historical atrocities and political oppression can create the conditions in which extremist organizations emerge. That’s hardly a revelation. But explaining the historical circumstances that contributed to the creation of Hamas does not establish that Hamas is justified in its actions. Causation is not justification. By your logic, virtually every extremist organization in history could excuse its atrocities by pointing to something that happened before its formation. That’s an intellectually bankrupt argument.
Second paragraph: At no point did I suggest that any Jewish person deserved to die, nor does my argument remotely imply that. I explicitly oppose the murder of innocent people, regardless of their ethnicity, religion, or nationality. Suggesting otherwise is either a spectacular failure of reading comprehension or a deliberate misrepresentation of what I said.
Your historical assertion about Muslims and antisemitism is equally ridiculous. Antisemitism in Muslim-majority societies has a long and complicated history that predates both World War II and the establishment of Israel. Relations between Muslim and Jewish communities varied considerably across centuries and geographical regions. Pretending antisemitism was essentially invented after World War II, or manufactured after 1967, is historical revisionism. Furthermore, Muslim empires conducted their own wars of conquest, religious persecution, and expansion. The historical record is considerably more complicated than the sanitized narrative you’re attempting to present.
Third paragraph: I never claimed the Muslim Brotherhood engaged in random violence against Jews. That’s an argument you invented because apparently responding to what I actually said was too difficult. Political and ideological violence is rarely random. That doesn’t make it justified. Understanding the motivations behind an organization is not the same thing as endorsing its conduct.
Your fourth paragraph is where your argument completely falls apart. You accuse me of supposedly suggesting that some Jews deserved to die, then explicitly declare that Hamas is entirely justified in everything it has done, including murdering civilians. Do you understand the contradiction? You are defending the very principle you’re accusing me of advocating: that civilians can be legitimate targets because of their nationality, political circumstances, or perceived collective responsibility.
You don’t get to condemn collective punishment in one breath and endorse the murder of civilians in the next. That isn’t a coherent moral position. It’s hypocrisy.
Finally, your last paragraph and accompanying links don’t establish what you seem to think they establish. You are conflating public opinion, political attitudes, participation in military operations, and collective responsibility as though they are interchangeable concepts. They aren’t. A poll showing support for a particular policy does not establish that every member of a population is responsible for it, much less that civilians are legitimate targets for violence. Nor does it establish that every Israeli supports genocide or has participated in military operations. Your sources do not demonstrate the conclusions you’re drawing from them.
And this brings us to the fundamental problem with your entire position: you seem incapable of distinguishing between explaining why an organization exists, understanding the grievances that motivate its supporters, and morally justifying its actions.
Those are three entirely different things.
You can acknowledge Palestinian suffering, condemn Israeli atrocities, recognize the historical circumstances that contributed to the emergence of Hamas, and still unequivocally condemn Hamas for murdering civilians. There is absolutely no contradiction in doing so.
The only contradiction here is yours. You have constructed an argument in which violence against civilians is reprehensible when you dislike the perpetrator, but entirely justified when you approve of the political cause.
I suggest you seriously reconsider the moral and intellectual foundations of that position before lecturing anyone else about genocide, historical context, or human rights.
What in the ever-loving fuck is this comment? Are you sick in the head or something?
At no point does my “logic” imply that some Jews deserved to die. In fact, I explicitly stated that no one should ever have to endure genocide and that nothing ever justifies it.
And I never made the implication that Muslims do anything to Jews I never even mentioned Jews one time. Jews is not synonymous with Israel.
And Hamas being the “least violent resistance group”? What the fuck does that even mean? That’s like saying the Korean War was the least violent war. You’re disgusting.
And what are these links you’ve posted, with all this contrived drivel? They’re completely out of context and have absolutely nothing to do with the point you’re trying to make. What the hell are you even talking about?
That statement doesn’t make sense ISIS is not a people, it’s a terrorist organization. Not a trick question, but definitely one that doesn’t make sense.
ISIS is objectively a terrorist organization composed of radicalized, violent individuals pursuing a very specific political and ideological agenda. They are not an indigenous population, an ethnic group, or a civilian population defined by geography. They are an organized terrorist organization. There is a fundamental difference, and pretending otherwise demonstrates a remarkable inability to distinguish between categories of people and political movements.
And before you attempt to conflate this with religion, there is no such thing as a Muslim terrorist as a distinct category of terrorism. There are terrorists. Their religious affiliation does not somehow redefine the nature of their crimes or grant them immunity from accountability.
ISIS would happily commit genocide against entire populations if those populations failed to conform to its ideology. They have demonstrated precisely that willingness. So spare me the manufactured moral equivalence. I have no obligation to extend sympathy to an organization whose explicit ambitions include the systematic extermination of people it considers undesirable.
And as for Gaza, your apparent difficulty understanding the scale of the devastation is almost comical. Open Google Earth. Look at the satellite imagery. Look at what remains of entire neighborhoods. This is not some obscure, difficult-to-access piece of information requiring specialized research or an advanced degree in geopolitical analysis. It is quite literally one of the easiest things you could do to educate yourself.
The fact that I have to explain the distinction between a terrorist organization and a civilian population while simultaneously directing you to satellite imagery to establish the physical reality of Gaza is genuinely embarrassing. At some point, intellectual dishonesty stops being an excuse for ignorance and becomes a conscious choice.
Apple has replaced the map images with previous ones, so it looks like the buildings are still there. I bet Google does too. Disgusting pieces of shit.
Ya… It looks like Google has practically redacted or replaced large swaths of the destruction with older satellite imagery. You can still see some destruction but not remotely as much.
I get your frustration and you’re probably right about the person you are responding to.
But I feel like it’s easy to forget thatnthere are teenagers and young adults who simply do not have the information to rationally connect the dots or just haven’t been involved in international politics.
In a vacuum it’s a completely understandable question to ask. In context it’s obviously leading and the comparison is gross…but sometimes people say ignorant shit while they are learning.
I’m probably being too generous but I always think about some of the questions my kid asks when trying to figure out the world.
For you ISIS are so bad that they deserved to be genocided. (You’re incorrect about the ethnic and local connection btw, but that isn’t really the point here). Men, women and children under the axe until they were defeated.
For a lot of Israelis, Hamas are such bad people that they deserve to be genocided. In the Balkans, a lot of people thought that their neighbours were such bad people that they had no right to the land and had to be genocided.
With one question you’ve gone from “Hamas is a terrorist organisation but nonetheless, genocide is never justified” to “ISIS is a terrorist organisation so the genocide was totally justified”
You clearly don’t understand what genocide means, and frankly, I’m not interested in debating the definition with you.
There is absolutely no credible argument, evidence, or rhetorical gymnastics that can establish that Israel is not committing genocide against the ethnic population of Gaza. It is. That is an established reality, not a matter of opinion.
More importantly, you cannot commit genocide against ISIS in the same sense that you cannot commit genocide against members of the YMCA. ISIS is an organization, not an ethnic population. Eliminating an organization, regardless of how reprehensible its members may be, is not inherently genocide.
Furthermore, I have never advocated for eliminating ISIS. I have never advocated for killing a single person, for any reason. I oppose the death penalty. I don’t believe anyone should be put to death. So why are you inventing positions for me? You are arguing against a position I have never held, apparently because you cannot address what I actually said.
And let’s be perfectly clear about something: if your position is that Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza, you are a genocide denier. You are lying about an atrocity that has been extensively documented. I don’t believe this is a matter of innocent disagreement or a difference in interpretation. At some point, dismissing the evidence and insisting that an established atrocity isn’t happening becomes deliberate dishonesty. You are a liar, and I have absolutely no interest in pretending otherwise or extending the courtesy of civilized debate to someone who refuses to engage with reality.
When you say “ISIS so bad. I have no obligation to extend sympathy” wrt a genocide being put on them, what else does it mean than that you at least not oppose their elimination?
ISIS is an organisation, not an ethnic population
ISIS was like 90+% indiginous people, even more when they started as a resistance group in Iraq. They were part of the population that wanted to see ‘their’ territory cleaned and brought under their control.
if your position is that Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza
If ISIS were to be dismantled, eliminated, defeated, or otherwise destroyed, I wouldn’t lose a moment of sleep over it. They’re a terrorist organization that has absolutely no qualms about murdering innocent people, publicly beheading captives, and committing atrocities to advance their political agenda.
And I am not going to engage with you in a never-ending battle of definitions and semantics. You cannot commit genocide against an organization. Genocide is the attempted destruction of a protected human population based on its national, ethnic, racial, or religious identity. ISIS is an organization, not a protected population.
The fact that ISIS has historically been composed largely of indigenous people from the territories in which it operated doesn’t change that distinction. Eliminating ISIS as an organization is not the same thing as exterminating Iraqis, Syrians, Muslims, or any other population.
And what makes me think you might have a problem with that distinction? Oh, I don’t know… Perhaps your apparent willingness to defend a violent terrorist organization that has demonstrated, time and time again, its willingness to murder, torture, and exterminate people who don’t subscribe to its ideology?
The Islamic State was just that: a caliphate vying to be a state for salafist sunnis. With their own governance, education, currency etc. . You might not like it. I might not like it. But that doesn’t mean they did not have a society built on their religious and cultural identity. It’s just that you decide that this identity is so utterly shit that you don’t want to consider it to be something worthy to be protected from genocide.
your apparent willingness to defend a violent terrorist organization
ISIS is an organization in the same sense that Microsoft is an organization or the Republican Party is an organization. There aren’t even that many members, probably somewhere around 18,000 worldwide, spread across various factions and geographical regions. You cannot commit genocide against an organization as the term is currently defined. ISIS does not constitute a society, any more than Microsoft or the Republican Party constitutes a society.
You are being disingenuous and arguing in bad faith. You have misrepresented my position through an enormous straw man. And don’t ask me what your straw man is. You clearly don’t understand what a straw man argument is, and I’m not going to explain it to you.
You keep asking what makes me think you’re denying genocide and supporting ISIS. It’s the language you’re using in your responses. Your own words are what lead me to that conclusion. Stop asking me to explain your own position to you. You know what you’re saying, and you know the implications of your own arguments.
Reading through the comments here.
Let me make something absolutely crystal clear
ISRAEL IS COMMITTING GENOCIDE.
The figure of 700,000 is entirely fabricated. The officially documented death toll is in the 70,000s. Those are confirmed deaths, and there are hundreds of thousands of people still missing, many of whom are likely buried beneath the enormous quantities of rubble that once constituted much of the Gaza Strip.
Israel does not inherently have a right to exist. This is a line that gets repeated constantly, but it is fundamentally meaningless. No country has an inherent right to exist simply because it is a country. The land itself doesn’t care what borders humanity draws across it or what names we assign to those territories. The United States doesn’t have an inherent right to exist either.
People, however, have the right to exist.
Hamas has committed horrific acts of violence throughout its existence, including since Israel became a country. By any reasonable definition, it is a terrorist organization. I have no interest in defending Hamas or excusing its atrocities. However, none of that changes the fundamental issue: the people currently responsible for carrying out what increasingly constitutes genocide are the Zionist leadership in power in Israel.
Genocide is never justified. Not under any circumstances, not in retaliation, not in the name of national security, and certainly not in the name of historical grievances.
People have a right to exist. Governments do not have an unlimited right to commit atrocities in the name of protecting their existence.
Very reasonable. If I may add:
We shouldn’t downplay the suffering of any widespread murder, genocide, but I just want to bring proportional attention to another atrocity:
Trump, Musk, and all enabling Republicans are responsible for at least 600,000 deaths in just 1 year’s time by the gutting of USAID known to have massive repercussions globally, and dwarfing the civilian death toll in Gaza and Ukraine, combined.
This matters because I still see a lot of people espousing false equivalence both sides bullshit on the two parties, and the truth is that these deaths simply would not have occurred under a Kamala Harris presidency. Food for thought.
On a separate note: AIPAC is calling in their favor to their Senators you see people from Mark Kelly to Kirsten Gillibrand bending the knee for Schumer. Call your Senators and tell them you’ll support their primary candidate next cycle and that you won’t support any of their Presidential bids in the future if they don’t support Van Hollen.
I’ve been telling mine that if he votes for schumer I will make it my life’s mission to replace him. I’ll go door to door. I’m disabled and I have all the time in the world.
I think we need to distinguish between the consequences of government policy and what legally or conceptually constitutes genocide. Gutting USAID was an extraordinarily destructive policy decision, and I understand the argument that its consequences will be measured in hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths. However, government policies that result in widespread death, even when those consequences are foreseeable, do not automatically constitute genocide. We could point to numerous examples of other countries making similarly destructive policy decisions with devastating consequences for civilian populations.
I also think there is a broader philosophical question here. At some point, we have to acknowledge that other countries bear responsibility for the welfare of their own populations. America cannot simultaneously be expected to police the world, finance the humanitarian needs of every struggling nation, and dictate how other governments conduct their affairs. That doesn’t mean we should abandon humanitarian assistance. Personally, I would have continued USAID funding precisely because the human consequences of eliminating it were so foreseeable. I would consider that the responsible and rational decision. Unfortunately, those qualities appear to be in rather short supply in the current administration.
Ultimately, I agree with your broader criticism of the administration and the devastating consequences of its decisions. I simply think we should be precise about the language we use and the responsibility we assign.
As for Israel and AIPAC, I don’t find any of this particularly surprising. Of course Israel wants American politicians who advance its interests. The problem is when foreign interests, through lobbying, political financing, and other forms of influence, become so deeply embedded in American politics that elected representatives appear more concerned with accommodating those interests than representing their own constituents. We’ve been watching that dynamic play out for years, and it deserves considerably more scrutiny than it receives.
Foreign interests shouldn’t be embedded at all in American internal politics, regardless. Including America’s meddling in other nation’s elections.
But I don’t respectfully think we need to spit hairs over this, if one’s activism priority is indeed the humanitarian and well-being of civilians, notably children – independent of nation-state and independent of strict legal definitions.
At the end of the day, it’s evidence that elections matter and evidence that 600,000 people (and rising) would be alive all over the world if not for a policy decision of a particular administration from elsewhere — no different than the policy decision of enabling aid to Israel. Whether that’s for wars, or for equipment for that.
Sorry but I lean toward the left, and I don’t engage in this bootstrapian rhetoric of, “fend for yourselves” — especially within the purview of this discussion where we are often responsible as well for the regional instability made in the first place. If outside forces are responsible for the instability, then even more so there is a humanitarian endeavor ot make it better. But no different than the aspirations of JFK and the Peace Corps and an underlying principle of the left, those who have the capacity to help have the obligation to do so.
So let’s not lose sight of our values and goals, and not get in the weeds of the games we often see those Zionists themselves play equivocal semantic games of, “Well is it a conflict, or a war; is it a genocide, or is it just reasonable collateral damage?” — It’s preventable death of innocent human lives, be it USAID revocation or strikes on densely-populated urban areas of Gaza or Russia’s cruel strikes on sovereign Ukrainian hospitals and schools just the same.
Israel was founded in 1987?
No. It was founded in 1948 following what the Palestinian people call the Nakba. A forceful relocation of the indigenous people of the area to accommodate for the people moving in. That in and of itself was already an atrocity.
Where the hell did you get 1987?
“Hamas has committed horrific acts of violence throughout its existence, including since Israel became a country.”
Hamas was founded in 1987 by victims of Israel’s genocide, therefore Israel started in 1987, according to you.
I see what you’re saying. I may have worded my original statement poorly. What I meant to convey is that Hamas did not emerge in a historical vacuum. Its emergence was shaped by decades of Israeli policies, occupation, displacement, and violence against the Palestinian population, long before Hamas was formally established in 1987.
Hamas grew out of the Palestinian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood, whose presence in Palestine dates back to the 1940s. The broader Muslim Brotherhood movement itself was founded in Egypt in 1928. In other words, the ideological and organizational foundations that eventually produced Hamas had existed for decades before the organization formally came into existence.
I would argue that Hamas was a foreseeable consequence of the historical conditions in which it emerged. That does not excuse its actions or justify attacks against civilians, but understanding the circumstances that produced the organization requires examining the decades of Palestinian displacement, occupation, repression, and violence that preceded its formation.
The point is that 1987 marks the formal establishment of Hamas, not the beginning of the historical circumstances, political grievances, or ideological movements that ultimately gave rise to it.
I would simply reply, like I always do to ‘but hamas bad,’ that Hamas would not exist, nor any revolutionary counter-terrorist organization like Hamas would exist, if zionists did not start killing Palestinians in the 1910s.
I would also point out that your logic means at least some Jews deserved the Holocaust which is generally understood to be a shitty thing to say. Muslims were not antisemitic for the vast majority of their history. This association only happened post WWII, incidentally this concept only breached mainstream society post 1967 to explain why so many muslim-majority countries “attacked” Israel.
This weird myth that is implied by your argument, that the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood randomly did violence against Jews for no reason, is counter to the rest of your argument, that you should take in the historical and material reasons for resistance groups like Hamas to exist and use violence.
To make my position clear, **not only is Hamas explicitly and entirely justified in all actions they have taken, including against ‘civilians’, they have been the least violent resistance group in history considering the conditions that lead to their creation."
You will not ever find a Perfect Victim. People being genocided will fight back, and will fight back against the entire nation that explicitly supports itt[1][2][3][[4 {Warning, Mossad-Linked Site, use no-script}]](https://www.inss.org.il/publication/israel-war-support/, half of which participated in it directly.
My initial response to your comment was mostly out of shock of what you said. Congratulations! You are the first person to actually shock me on this platform. It’s morning for me now and I’ve had a good night’s sleep. I’ve had a moment to properly rebuttal. Your contrived bullshit. Please enjoy your own evisceration.
Your entire argument is a collection of historical distortions, straw men, and logical contradictions. Let’s address them individually.
First paragraph: What exactly is your point? Yes, historical atrocities and political oppression can create the conditions in which extremist organizations emerge. That’s hardly a revelation. But explaining the historical circumstances that contributed to the creation of Hamas does not establish that Hamas is justified in its actions. Causation is not justification. By your logic, virtually every extremist organization in history could excuse its atrocities by pointing to something that happened before its formation. That’s an intellectually bankrupt argument.
Second paragraph: At no point did I suggest that any Jewish person deserved to die, nor does my argument remotely imply that. I explicitly oppose the murder of innocent people, regardless of their ethnicity, religion, or nationality. Suggesting otherwise is either a spectacular failure of reading comprehension or a deliberate misrepresentation of what I said.
Your historical assertion about Muslims and antisemitism is equally ridiculous. Antisemitism in Muslim-majority societies has a long and complicated history that predates both World War II and the establishment of Israel. Relations between Muslim and Jewish communities varied considerably across centuries and geographical regions. Pretending antisemitism was essentially invented after World War II, or manufactured after 1967, is historical revisionism. Furthermore, Muslim empires conducted their own wars of conquest, religious persecution, and expansion. The historical record is considerably more complicated than the sanitized narrative you’re attempting to present.
Third paragraph: I never claimed the Muslim Brotherhood engaged in random violence against Jews. That’s an argument you invented because apparently responding to what I actually said was too difficult. Political and ideological violence is rarely random. That doesn’t make it justified. Understanding the motivations behind an organization is not the same thing as endorsing its conduct.
Your fourth paragraph is where your argument completely falls apart. You accuse me of supposedly suggesting that some Jews deserved to die, then explicitly declare that Hamas is entirely justified in everything it has done, including murdering civilians. Do you understand the contradiction? You are defending the very principle you’re accusing me of advocating: that civilians can be legitimate targets because of their nationality, political circumstances, or perceived collective responsibility.
You don’t get to condemn collective punishment in one breath and endorse the murder of civilians in the next. That isn’t a coherent moral position. It’s hypocrisy.
Finally, your last paragraph and accompanying links don’t establish what you seem to think they establish. You are conflating public opinion, political attitudes, participation in military operations, and collective responsibility as though they are interchangeable concepts. They aren’t. A poll showing support for a particular policy does not establish that every member of a population is responsible for it, much less that civilians are legitimate targets for violence. Nor does it establish that every Israeli supports genocide or has participated in military operations. Your sources do not demonstrate the conclusions you’re drawing from them.
And this brings us to the fundamental problem with your entire position: you seem incapable of distinguishing between explaining why an organization exists, understanding the grievances that motivate its supporters, and morally justifying its actions.
Those are three entirely different things.
You can acknowledge Palestinian suffering, condemn Israeli atrocities, recognize the historical circumstances that contributed to the emergence of Hamas, and still unequivocally condemn Hamas for murdering civilians. There is absolutely no contradiction in doing so.
The only contradiction here is yours. You have constructed an argument in which violence against civilians is reprehensible when you dislike the perpetrator, but entirely justified when you approve of the political cause.
I suggest you seriously reconsider the moral and intellectual foundations of that position before lecturing anyone else about genocide, historical context, or human rights.
What in the ever-loving fuck is this comment? Are you sick in the head or something?
At no point does my “logic” imply that some Jews deserved to die. In fact, I explicitly stated that no one should ever have to endure genocide and that nothing ever justifies it.
And I never made the implication that Muslims do anything to Jews I never even mentioned Jews one time. Jews is not synonymous with Israel.
And Hamas being the “least violent resistance group”? What the fuck does that even mean? That’s like saying the Korean War was the least violent war. You’re disgusting.
And what are these links you’ve posted, with all this contrived drivel? They’re completely out of context and have absolutely nothing to do with the point you’re trying to make. What the hell are you even talking about?
Jesus.
Where did 1987 come from?
Hamas was founded in 1987 by victims of Israel’s genocide and surviving family members.
Would you say the genocide against ISIS was justified?
(Not a trick question or something, just that I would argue that, sometimes, it’s not so easy)
That statement doesn’t make sense ISIS is not a people, it’s a terrorist organization. Not a trick question, but definitely one that doesn’t make sense.
You might call them a terrorist organisation, but they see themselves as the locals freeing themselves from foreign and religious oppression.
Dehumanizing them into ‘not real people’ is just trying to make it go down easier
Removed by mod
ISIS is objectively a terrorist organization composed of radicalized, violent individuals pursuing a very specific political and ideological agenda. They are not an indigenous population, an ethnic group, or a civilian population defined by geography. They are an organized terrorist organization. There is a fundamental difference, and pretending otherwise demonstrates a remarkable inability to distinguish between categories of people and political movements.
And before you attempt to conflate this with religion, there is no such thing as a Muslim terrorist as a distinct category of terrorism. There are terrorists. Their religious affiliation does not somehow redefine the nature of their crimes or grant them immunity from accountability.
ISIS would happily commit genocide against entire populations if those populations failed to conform to its ideology. They have demonstrated precisely that willingness. So spare me the manufactured moral equivalence. I have no obligation to extend sympathy to an organization whose explicit ambitions include the systematic extermination of people it considers undesirable.
And as for Gaza, your apparent difficulty understanding the scale of the devastation is almost comical. Open Google Earth. Look at the satellite imagery. Look at what remains of entire neighborhoods. This is not some obscure, difficult-to-access piece of information requiring specialized research or an advanced degree in geopolitical analysis. It is quite literally one of the easiest things you could do to educate yourself.
The fact that I have to explain the distinction between a terrorist organization and a civilian population while simultaneously directing you to satellite imagery to establish the physical reality of Gaza is genuinely embarrassing. At some point, intellectual dishonesty stops being an excuse for ignorance and becomes a conscious choice.
Apple has replaced the map images with previous ones, so it looks like the buildings are still there. I bet Google does too. Disgusting pieces of shit.
Ya… It looks like Google has practically redacted or replaced large swaths of the destruction with older satellite imagery. You can still see some destruction but not remotely as much.
Fucking sick.
I get your frustration and you’re probably right about the person you are responding to.
But I feel like it’s easy to forget thatnthere are teenagers and young adults who simply do not have the information to rationally connect the dots or just haven’t been involved in international politics.
In a vacuum it’s a completely understandable question to ask. In context it’s obviously leading and the comparison is gross…but sometimes people say ignorant shit while they are learning.
I’m probably being too generous but I always think about some of the questions my kid asks when trying to figure out the world.
Removed by mod
Anybody that denies the genocide currently happening in Gaza does not get the benefit of the doubt from me. They will be dealt with expeditiously.
Well that’s the point I’m making, of course.
For you ISIS are so bad that they deserved to be genocided. (You’re incorrect about the ethnic and local connection btw, but that isn’t really the point here). Men, women and children under the axe until they were defeated.
For a lot of Israelis, Hamas are such bad people that they deserve to be genocided. In the Balkans, a lot of people thought that their neighbours were such bad people that they had no right to the land and had to be genocided.
With one question you’ve gone from “Hamas is a terrorist organisation but nonetheless, genocide is never justified” to “ISIS is a terrorist organisation so the genocide was totally justified”
You clearly don’t understand what genocide means, and frankly, I’m not interested in debating the definition with you.
There is absolutely no credible argument, evidence, or rhetorical gymnastics that can establish that Israel is not committing genocide against the ethnic population of Gaza. It is. That is an established reality, not a matter of opinion.
More importantly, you cannot commit genocide against ISIS in the same sense that you cannot commit genocide against members of the YMCA. ISIS is an organization, not an ethnic population. Eliminating an organization, regardless of how reprehensible its members may be, is not inherently genocide.
Furthermore, I have never advocated for eliminating ISIS. I have never advocated for killing a single person, for any reason. I oppose the death penalty. I don’t believe anyone should be put to death. So why are you inventing positions for me? You are arguing against a position I have never held, apparently because you cannot address what I actually said.
And let’s be perfectly clear about something: if your position is that Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza, you are a genocide denier. You are lying about an atrocity that has been extensively documented. I don’t believe this is a matter of innocent disagreement or a difference in interpretation. At some point, dismissing the evidence and insisting that an established atrocity isn’t happening becomes deliberate dishonesty. You are a liar, and I have absolutely no interest in pretending otherwise or extending the courtesy of civilized debate to someone who refuses to engage with reality.
When you say “ISIS so bad. I have no obligation to extend sympathy” wrt a genocide being put on them, what else does it mean than that you at least not oppose their elimination?
ISIS was like 90+% indiginous people, even more when they started as a resistance group in Iraq. They were part of the population that wanted to see ‘their’ territory cleaned and brought under their control.
What makes you think that?
If ISIS were to be dismantled, eliminated, defeated, or otherwise destroyed, I wouldn’t lose a moment of sleep over it. They’re a terrorist organization that has absolutely no qualms about murdering innocent people, publicly beheading captives, and committing atrocities to advance their political agenda.
And I am not going to engage with you in a never-ending battle of definitions and semantics. You cannot commit genocide against an organization. Genocide is the attempted destruction of a protected human population based on its national, ethnic, racial, or religious identity. ISIS is an organization, not a protected population.
The fact that ISIS has historically been composed largely of indigenous people from the territories in which it operated doesn’t change that distinction. Eliminating ISIS as an organization is not the same thing as exterminating Iraqis, Syrians, Muslims, or any other population.
And what makes me think you might have a problem with that distinction? Oh, I don’t know… Perhaps your apparent willingness to defend a violent terrorist organization that has demonstrated, time and time again, its willingness to murder, torture, and exterminate people who don’t subscribe to its ideology?
The Islamic State was just that: a caliphate vying to be a state for salafist sunnis. With their own governance, education, currency etc. . You might not like it. I might not like it. But that doesn’t mean they did not have a society built on their religious and cultural identity. It’s just that you decide that this identity is so utterly shit that you don’t want to consider it to be something worthy to be protected from genocide.
What makes you think that?
ISIS is an organization in the same sense that Microsoft is an organization or the Republican Party is an organization. There aren’t even that many members, probably somewhere around 18,000 worldwide, spread across various factions and geographical regions. You cannot commit genocide against an organization as the term is currently defined. ISIS does not constitute a society, any more than Microsoft or the Republican Party constitutes a society.
You are being disingenuous and arguing in bad faith. You have misrepresented my position through an enormous straw man. And don’t ask me what your straw man is. You clearly don’t understand what a straw man argument is, and I’m not going to explain it to you.
You keep asking what makes me think you’re denying genocide and supporting ISIS. It’s the language you’re using in your responses. Your own words are what lead me to that conclusion. Stop asking me to explain your own position to you. You know what you’re saying, and you know the implications of your own arguments.