I wonder if the Redditors will ever get mad enough to leave. One can hope.
They were useless anyway. In a place that big with that much movement you can sort posts however you want that if you refresh in a few seconds you may see a completely different front page.
Even if there weren’t interests on what to show you the result would be pretty close to it in an attempt to organise the unwieldy.
You will view our prioritized, paid content and be grateful.
For quite a long time, I saw posts here saying that Reddit had removed r/All. I mentioned a workaround here many times (yes, I have had more than one account here - sorry?). Some of this may be my fault, though I doubt it. I mentioned the workaround I had for both accessing App from the app and old Reddit after they had attempted to shudder it on Reddit itself. Days later, both loopholes closed.
So far, RedReader has worked well for me for occasional browsing/looking stuff up there. I think I got it through fdroid. Still allows viewing all posts, sorting by new/top/etc…
Oh damn thanks for this. I wonder if the no login access will break apps like this for good?
no login access
Are they still doing this? It showed up for me for a few days and then went away again. When it was active using ublock to zap the login message restored site functionality.
And old.reddit isn’t even accessible to new users anymore. And they’ll ban old.reddit from your account if you don’t log into it once every 60 days.
Lmao wtf
Wait so what does subscribing to a sub mean now? Sucks that Reddit is so important in niche hobbies but terrible in every other way.
I’m still a bit amazed they got rid of r/all.
(Yes I know old reddit still exists. I don’t know how anyone uses that site without it or third party whatsits)Kinda want to thank them for being awful enough to push me to try something else, like Microsoft.
Yes I know old reddit still exists.
For now, they are currently bleeding it dry (the userbase is locked down, it’s not possible to become a new old reddit user anymore). It’s basically just rotting in a cell waiting for its death sentence at this point.
they want people to use the recycled slop on the “best” popular feed , which has all the ragebaiting content.
It feels like 70% of the content is video now. Like it’s trying to be endless scroll tiktok videos.
I remember just reading and reading and being so happy to have a group of people who seemed to be matched with my education level on the topics I like. Links to scholary articles and being able to talk to people who had also read and fully comprehended the text. There’d be quotes from individuals I knew from deep deep university work, and it was so cool.
Now yeah. It’s just videos and weird gross sexual anime.
its either that or memes, or politics, or the fake stories posts like AITA, girl and boy dinner diaries. like every 3rd post is one of those aita /diaries posts, and it seems you cant call out the story for being AI generated or bot posted anymore.
The dinner diary shit is so low effort it kills me. Here’s a picture of a my sad lasagna, my SO doesn’t love me.
This is like 50 percent of front page content now.
Nice to see a few Piefed and Lemmy mentions there.
I welcome any new users with open arms! Reddit’s been on a constant downward slope since I left, and still shows no signs of stopping. It’s slower but hopefully people recognize there’s no profit motive for engagement so the comments and posts that are here generally are higher quality.
Yeah so many posts asking what alternatives there are to reddit and I’m like come on damn. The Fediverse needs better marketing.
Lemmy mods are just as censorious as those on Reddit. And both hide their censorship shenanigans from other users.
Some are, some aren’t. It’s federated so you can choose to block who you don’t like and so can they. If a community sucks, start another one that’s better.
Thing is, because it’s open source, public modlog and federated, when there was censorship, even one egregious and intentionally hidden case, eventually got found out. People were up in arms, and moved to other/forked ways to access the same Fediverse.
As for moderation I’ve said repeatedly that it’s like fiefdoms instead of kingdoms, so while of course there is no shortage of shitty mods like almost any site, you can’t have a site admin unilaterally enforce a rule that applies to every community on the fediverse. The decentralized nature is inherently very resistant to that.
I can’t even find them anymore, but I swear there were articles sometime around 2015-2016ish commenting on a slowdown of the feeds. I noticed it, too. In the early days of Reddit there was so much content every time you refreshed the page, but then they fucked with the algorithm hard and posts lingered much longer. It’s been a long, slow decline and we’re at the point where the wheels are full coming off, but it’s been coming awhile no doubt.
EDIT: I half-heartedly tried to research this a bit but it’s really hard to surface articles I don’t remember many details on from near a decade ago with the internet in the state that it’s in. Looks like maybe around ~2018 they changed how Best/Hot was calculated and this resulted in slowing of new content onto feeds, I think that’s what I’m remembering …
I know what youre talking about posts started sticking around longer and the upvote count became inflated cuz posts would stick around way longer. You’d start seeing 3k upvotes on a post that was an hour old and users started spamming trash cuz even that would last long enough to be upvoted into olbivion
Once again everyone forgets the_donald. Right wing trolls figured out how to game the reddit feed so they can control exactly what posts are in what specific order /r/all.
Does no one remember when they used to make it show Trump’s face across multiple post thumbnails?
That’s why it had to be nerfed. Whatever determines the feed isn’t organic user activity because trolls will manipulate it. The feeds people see most definitely curated in some way. It’s been this way since just after 2016.
It sounds like, based on what youre describing, that the users figured out how to game the algorithm, but the moderation tools at the time were not up to the task of identifying the abusive behavior. So, rather than address the problem, they altered their algorithm to cover over it, which created a new problem intrinsic to the system that made the decisions on what a user sees into a mystery.
When the epstein files dropped they did weird shit with anime porn. r/all was a battlefield of bots pushing that gross shit covering up the legitimate posts that were actually leading to relevant good discussions too.
That’s why I kept on looking at reddit for a long time. It’s not about the content you see. There tends to be some meta going on. People look at it to laugh at the memes, thinking it’s random silliness. There’s more to it than meets the eye.
. . trolls. Da.
And before the_donald it was Ron Paul spam.
I assume Lemmy clients will adapt the same way in the future.
Or is it instances that determine the “all” algorithm?
There’s no standard algorithm, each instance could theoretically use a different one. Piefed / pylova does use a different one from lemmy, in fact.
They were on lisp right? At some point? I forget when they did the first “redesign”. You could see everything before that. up/down votes. There were even metadata sites that helped so you could see when a bandwagon happened.
As far as I remember, they only used Lisp at very early stage, primarily because Paul Graham would not finance them otherwise. By the time they introduced subreddits, they were already on Python. And closing down the access to voting data happened later still.
They started with Lisp, and eventually did a rewrite in python for performance reasons. There was even an open source version for a bit, not there’s a point to that anymore. Y Combinator and Paul Graham might’ve been mentioned in those days.
I’ve joined Reddit 18 years ago when there weren’t even subreddits and AFAIR back then the rewrite was mentioned as something that already happened.
The removal of down votes definitively was after that.
If anyone is interested in old style Reddit (around when subreddit were introduced, but were still fixed) then tildes.net might be a good option.
Tildes is a delightful community unless you get on the bad side of the owner, which I managed to do. Someone lost their temper at me and I lost my temper back. I was permabanned and they were not. So it was nice… until it wasn’t.
Just be aware that there is that single point of judgment.
Same here. But I didn’t lose my temper; all I had to do was courteously insist he was wrong and bring receipts.
Tildes openly sports its so-called Benevolent Dictator for Life structure, and every now and again, as happens with dictators, he is full of factually incorrect shit and cannot bear evidence to the contrary, no matter how softly swathed.
I think I got temp banned and just left, but I didn’t sign up for that shit. I was so relieved when I found Lemmy.
You bring up a good point. I remember when getting “subreddits” was such a big deal. Before you just popped onto reddit, saw everything there was to look at, then go away for a day or so before that.
Reddit has generations of people that “remember” it now. Crazy.
Now it feels like a slot machine. Will the algorithm give me something I want to look at from my niche community I love? Or will I get gore/depression/ads…etc…?
Like r/FiftyFifty, but everywhere. How fun!
I can’t remember exactly when I first joined reddit, but remember being on it in my high-school library back in 2010 so I’ve been around. It’s been a major disappointment in my life watching all the socials get turned into mind control machines. That one especially. It was like my first college professor in a lot of ways.
Lurking tildes is free, but posting requires an invite, which the owner used to provide on email request but no longer does because AI spam is too overwhelming. I have a few if anyone wants.
I didn’t know it, that sucks.
The contacts page still says to email them though.
This is the way how I got there (had to wait few days) but it was in 2023 so at the time was just busy admitting Reddit refugees.
The Safereddit front end is working for me right now, if anyone wants to see the discussion:
“Reddit is refusing requests. Showing page from 12 minutes ago.”
We can’t have nice things
It’s hit or miss for me with Reddit front ends to start with; I guess we’re lucky it was up that long. Sorry about that.
Seeing people on there complain about the inevitable enshitification of centrally owned websites and anticipating the next Reddit replacement to appear so they can do the Digg exodus 2.0 is just…
I’d tell them, but I refuse to engage with that shithole.
Do the users there still refer to the digg exodus? I would have expected none of the current userbase to know what that is.
Thanks
oh neat! thanks!
When fb did that was when I left the place.
It is so ass, you made the right choice.
Fucking Reddit man
I can’t read that, and I can’t read the non-old version since now it only gives me a login wall.
Edit, OP’s comment (quite added)
Edit: want to see exactly what I’m talking about? Using old.reddit.com, this post is currently #3 on Hot for me. Where is it in the app…? It does not exist anywhere for me. Reddit will not let me see it. I would be interested to see if this is the same for anyone else
I’m extremely concerned about Reddit deliberately removing users’ ability to choose how they sort their feeds and what content they see.
I think it’s genuinely insidious that Reddit is increasingly taking control away from users and instead pushing us towards seeing only what Reddit’s algorithms decide we should see.
This has already significantly reduced my enjoyment of Reddit. I’ve gone from browsing for hours every day to spending just minutes on the platform, because I’m simply not willing to be forced into consuming whatever Reddit decides to put in front of me.
Users should be able to decide what they see, not have those decisions made for them. If I want to sort by New, Hot, Best or Top, that should be my choice.
I genuinely wonder how many Reddit users even realise that these choices are being taken away from them.
Please restore the sorting options and stop treating user control as something that can be quietly removed.
Thats a hilarious username by the way. [Object Object] haha
Speak English doctor!
Opened Lemmy because of this post.
Went to do the daily ninigram and ended up scrolling mindlessly. Saw this and asked myself why I was back in that hellhole











