Hi, student of psychology here. If this is normal for him, if it’s not interfering in his ability to live his life, not causing trouble for others, not leading to bad outcomes… then there’s no illness to speak of. It’s possible he could have a disorder, but that’s not something you can conclude just by the fact that he’s super weird.
I guess I wonder about the “if this is normal for him” part more than anything. My concern would be if he uses this in lieu of forming other personal connections or as a crutch or some sort for emotional support. I worry that maybe even if it’s normal for him he could maybe be using it to satisfy a want or need that would be better satisfied by a relationship with a person. I don’t know any psych stuff, but it feels possibly similar to an OCD situation, where addressing the root cause might decrease anxiety or the compulsion to do certain things. Just because the compulsions seem normal to that person doesn’t mean they come from a healthy place? Not sure if that’s relevant or makes sense in this context, but that’s where my concern mostly stems from.
The problem with OCD isn’t that it happens in and of itself, but that it causes disruption, distress, and lifestyle interference. It’s possible this man is struggling to fulfill a deep longing and this is the best he can do but it’s not good enough… and that’s something he’d have to see a therapist about. However, he could be someone for whom a doll is preferable to a real human for one reason or another. I know there are parts of my life that are super weird compared to society that for me are normal, and I’d be lying if I said I didn’t wish I could change one or two of those things. But at this point it’s only a problem when it causes me to clash with people, and to combat that I learn how to get along with people better. I don’t try to de-weird myself, I just make sure it doesn’t cause bad outcomes, and that’s treatment enough!
Hi, student of psychology here. If this is normal for him, if it’s not interfering in his ability to live his life, not causing trouble for others, not leading to bad outcomes… then there’s no illness to speak of. It’s possible he could have a disorder, but that’s not something you can conclude just by the fact that he’s super weird.
Hi, thank you for taking the time to reply!
I guess I wonder about the “if this is normal for him” part more than anything. My concern would be if he uses this in lieu of forming other personal connections or as a crutch or some sort for emotional support. I worry that maybe even if it’s normal for him he could maybe be using it to satisfy a want or need that would be better satisfied by a relationship with a person. I don’t know any psych stuff, but it feels possibly similar to an OCD situation, where addressing the root cause might decrease anxiety or the compulsion to do certain things. Just because the compulsions seem normal to that person doesn’t mean they come from a healthy place? Not sure if that’s relevant or makes sense in this context, but that’s where my concern mostly stems from.
The movie Lars and the Real Girl has a really compassionate take on why people do this kind of thing. It’s a surprisingly heartwarming film.
The problem with OCD isn’t that it happens in and of itself, but that it causes disruption, distress, and lifestyle interference. It’s possible this man is struggling to fulfill a deep longing and this is the best he can do but it’s not good enough… and that’s something he’d have to see a therapist about. However, he could be someone for whom a doll is preferable to a real human for one reason or another. I know there are parts of my life that are super weird compared to society that for me are normal, and I’d be lying if I said I didn’t wish I could change one or two of those things. But at this point it’s only a problem when it causes me to clash with people, and to combat that I learn how to get along with people better. I don’t try to de-weird myself, I just make sure it doesn’t cause bad outcomes, and that’s treatment enough!
That was a very helpful explanation! I again really appreciate the time you took to respond.
Thanks for the opportunity to yap about my major!