It’s not even unfortunate phrasing, it’s normal phrasing that normal people use, which is the exact reason AI uses it. Your accusations are just Kafka traps where talking like a normal human being is held up as proof they’re an AI.
I wasn’t accusing anyone, and @ComradeMiao@lemmy.world seems to have been convinced it’s not ai too. If they were even doubting it to begin with.
The thread is about why it feels like ai, it seems pretty clear that it is not actually ai.
Stuff feeling like ai comes about naturally due to the way that it is. “Talking about it is good actually” cause then you learn when to trust it and when not to, and learn to understand it better, and how others perceive it.
It’s a fact that using certain expressions in certain ways will now raise eyebrows.
Btw. specifically the “it’s not X it’s Y” one is conditioned on using it poorly (at least for me). I’m sure there are people that legitimately used it poorly before ai, like presumably war and peas here, but it’s definitely not common.
I mean if it was it wouldn’t be as strong a tell.
My “<adjective>, not X. <adjective>, Y” in comparison is a weaker tell. Maybe because it is used properly, or more commonly. Who knows.
Also ai doesn’t talk like normal people. It doesn’t even talk like professional writers, though it’s closer to modern pre-ai news article writing than most other styles.
I’m sure it would have the ability to get somewhat close to other styles too, since in initial training the llm will have been exposed to it all and “have to have used it”. But it is trained not to later on, and people generally don’t bother jailbreaking their ai to get it to talk more like a normal person.
Hence also “totally” just by itself being a strong no-ai tell.
The thread is about why it feels like ai, it seems pretty clear that it is not actually ai.
Stuff feeling like ai comes about naturally due to the way that it is. “Talking about it is good actually” cause then you learn when to trust it and when not to, and learn to understand it better, and how others perceive it.
It’s a fact that using certain expressions in certain ways will now raise eyebrows.
Thanks for a wonderful addition to this thread. Great point!
It’s not even unfortunate phrasing, it’s normal phrasing that normal people use, which is the exact reason AI uses it. Your accusations are just Kafka traps where talking like a normal human being is held up as proof they’re an AI.
I wasn’t accusing anyone, and @ComradeMiao@lemmy.world seems to have been convinced it’s not ai too. If they were even doubting it to begin with.
The thread is about why it feels like ai, it seems pretty clear that it is not actually ai.
Stuff feeling like ai comes about naturally due to the way that it is. “Talking about it is good actually” cause then you learn when to trust it and when not to, and learn to understand it better, and how others perceive it.
It’s a fact that using certain expressions in certain ways will now raise eyebrows.
Btw. specifically the “it’s not X it’s Y” one is conditioned on using it poorly (at least for me). I’m sure there are people that legitimately used it poorly before ai, like presumably war and peas here, but it’s definitely not common.
I mean if it was it wouldn’t be as strong a tell.
My “<adjective>, not X. <adjective>, Y” in comparison is a weaker tell. Maybe because it is used properly, or more commonly. Who knows.
Also ai doesn’t talk like normal people. It doesn’t even talk like professional writers, though it’s closer to modern pre-ai news article writing than most other styles.
I’m sure it would have the ability to get somewhat close to other styles too, since in initial training the llm will have been exposed to it all and “have to have used it”. But it is trained not to later on, and people generally don’t bother jailbreaking their ai to get it to talk more like a normal person.
Hence also “totally” just by itself being a strong no-ai tell.
Thanks for a wonderful addition to this thread. Great point!