• brucethemoose@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    134
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    23 hours ago

    Not most of them.

    Not from my impression scrolling though, anyway: https://www.metacritic.com/game/grand-theft-auto-vi/user-reviews/?platform=playstation-5

    Yep, there are some incel reviews. Most people complain about performance though, and this represents the second most common one I see:

    This game deserves apt praise for how it looks, as well as all the things the game has, regardless of how much one likes said content. The fact that they stuffed it all into one game is extremely impressive; the world design is something I think is great, and while that is typically a given for competently designed open worlds, this one is especially well crafted. The sheer scale of things to do is overwhelming, and it’s mind-boggling how much effort they went to make things feel as realistic as possible, and this is unfortunately where the positives end.

    This has been done to death, but the story is hideously bland and uninteresting, with some extremely boring characters that make it impossible to get truly immersed and invested. Much of the story content itself feels hollow because of this, and does not feel worth the sheer time investment required; it is neither fun on a gameplay level nor satisfying narratively.

    The sheer number of things possible made certain that a lot of the game would be severely lacking or underdeveloped, and the strict policy of realism has changed things both for the better and for the much, much worse. Can’t steal certain vehicles and all that.


    Or:

    In my first 10 hours, I fell through the map twice and lost progress on a mission both times. NPCs randomly T-pose in the middle of cutscenes, and vehicles spawn inside buildings or launch into the sky for no reason. Twice, a mission-critical character simply never showed up, forcing me to restart the whole **** AI is inconsistent. Police sometimes spot me through solid walls from across the city, yet other times they ignore me while I’m committing crimes right in front of them. Pedestrians clip through cars, and traffic occasionally freezes into a gridlock that never resolves.Performance is unstable…

    Some say the relationship is a huge part of the story, yet it feels “artificial” or unrealistic. They write it in a way that definitely isn’t incel to me.


    TL;DR: It’s unfair to write off the low score as incels. There’s clearly some stuff wrong with the release.

    …But it’s Metacritic. So it could mostly be bots.

    Who knows? Shrug.

    • boonhet@sopuli.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      2 hours ago

      It seems about half the negative reviews are complaining about woke. And those are the lowest ratings, usually 0 or 1. Then there are ones complaining about too much realism (fair I’d assume, I actually liked all the things you could do in RDR2 but a lot of people hated it) or Jason being boring af (haven’t played yet, don’t know - but the voice actor choice seemed REALLY bad from that extended preview, like dude was consistently trying to be a big muscular badass and it didn’t even fit the character model - if the writing was as bad as the VA choice, then I’d hate him too). Those negative reviews tend to be like 3 or 4.

      A few examples:

      0/10:

      Goy cuck auto 6. Had so many hopes and expectations, everything got ruined. Biggest downfall of the industry and the franchise will never recover from here

      0/10:

      Dunno what people expected from those devs but to no surprise the game came out as woke garbage. The game series about crime and heists and freedom of actions now restricts violence against particular minorities and tells a story of a man who does groceries, repairs house and endures completely awful behavior of his fiancé. The real right choice in this game should be to break up with that toxic woman and never to see her again Also, the game has been developed for 12 years but the bugs and fps stutters are still there, like Cyberpunk all over again I hope claude reverse engineers this abomination into something decent

      And my favourite one so far, this one being a whopping 1/10:

      One of my biggest concerns about GTA 6 is how much forced feminism and modern political messaging seem to be creeping into the game. GTA has always been known for its dark humor, satire, and unapologetic attitude. It shouldn’t turn into a platform for pushing modern ideological agendas. I want a GTA game that focuses on great storytelling, memorable characters, freedom, and genuine satire — not one that feels like it’s trying to lecture players about social issues. Rockstar should focus on making a great game instead of trying to please every political trend.

      WHEN HAS GTA NOT BEEN POLITICAL SATIRE?! These people think that since V poked a bit more fun at people they deem left-leaning (vain social media influencers and such - not necessarily ACTUALLY left-leaning, it’s just the image they’ve built in their heads), that it’s not been a series primarily making fun of right-wingers. The ads, radio talk shows, etc, were always making fun of conservatives lmao. It’s primarily a parody of the US. All of the US. There’s just usually more to make fun of on the conservative side.

      /rant

    • 87Six@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      6 hours ago

      Nonono they just hate it because it protects women, the trans, and vulnerable groups!!! Rebel against the incels!!!

    • UnethicalGallon@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      16
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      19 hours ago

      I’ve not looked at metacritic reviews, but from what I’ve been hearing. The long story short is the game makes you go through boring stuff before the exciting parts of the game. That’s objectively one of the biggest gripes with the game.

      Now of course there’s going to be right wing incels who look for reasons to be angry about their culture war stuff.

      • QuantumSparkles@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        5 hours ago

        Honestly there was a lot of that in RDR2 as well. I love that game so much but there is a lot of this weird, forced tedium and aspects of obsessive need for “realism” that take away from the fact that it’s a video game at the end of the day

        • dreamkeeper@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          5 hours ago

          Loved RDR2 as well but I don’t think that’s what GTA fans want. They’re different franchises for a reason. I’m kinda surprised Rockstar leaned into that gameplay style for GTA. Not that I care that much because I mostly liked it in RDR2, although I’m admit the intro is a pretty big slog.