• Warl0k3@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    4 hours ago

    Oh my god, I can’t believe I got you to go full “le logical fallacy” in like, two comments. Spectacular. Argumentum ad logicam, here we go!

    Aaaaaanyways, I didn’t dismiss your arguments on the basis that you’re MAGA, I pointed out they were MAGA talking points. You just merrily leaped to the convenient conclusion I was dismissing your argument based on the association with MAGA, instead of inviting the comparison between the things you are saying and the groups that say them. The drivel you’re spewing while trying to act like this is some kind of formal debate has already been exhaustively debunked and I’m not trying to change your mind, I’m just trying to show you that your trolling ain’t gonna fly here. Also, trying to assert your hate has to be tolerated is funny, claiming that McWhorter et. whoever-the-fuck-don’t-care are liberals (well obviously yes, but not the sort of liberal you clearly mean) is hilarious and attempting to posture as though you’re the injured party here is downright sidesplitting.

    Anyways, have fun with that.

    • berno@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      4 hours ago

      I already said I am not MAGA, and that this criticism is not scoped to one side. You ignored both and went back to the tribe label. “Argumentum ad logicam” means rejecting a conclusion because the reasoning was bad. I did not do that. I said your reply had no reasoning at all, only a tribe label. Naming a fallacy is not a fallacy. “I invited a comparison” is the same move: you named who else says it and never said what is false about it. “Exhaustively debunked,” and you still have not named one debunking. “I’m not trying to change your mind, just showing your trolling won’t fly here” is not a debate. It is a room being policed. “Your hate” was read into a comment that contained none, because the verdict was already written. “Not the sort of liberal” is the rescue hatch: any liberal who disagrees gets reclassified on the spot so the label survives. And then “have fun with that.” Declare it settled, announce you were never persuading, slam the door. You did not answer the point. You sentenced it. That is exactly how a Red Guard works: the crowd does not test the claim, it names the heretic and the sentence is the whole proceeding.