The paradox of tolerance is a rule about conduct, not a license to skip the definition. Popper’s limit is on people who would end debate by force. Disagreeing with an ideology is not that, and calling it hate does not make it that. “I don’t reward hate” is the verdict again, written before the argument was read. You still have not said what woke is. You have only said you will not answer, and then treated the refusal as proof you were right. That is not tolerance. That is a closed room.
Once again: just because you’re demanding that I do something doesn’t mean I have to do it. I know it’s worryingly hard to accept, but just because you want something doesn’t mean other people have to give it to you.
You don’t have to define it. You also don’t get to call the definition wrong, the argument debunked, or the criticism hate, while refusing to say what the word means. “I don’t have to” is not an answer. It is the refusal, said out loud. A word you will not define cannot convict anyone.
That refusal is the system. The charge works only if the word stays undefined. Define woke and it can be tested, and a tested charge can fail. Leave it undefined and it can be applied to anyone, and the denial is taken as proof. That is why you will not say what it means. A heresy with no definition cannot be answered, only confessed to. “I don’t have to” is not a rebuttal. It is the clergy declining to show the accused the statute.
That is not the demand. The demand was: if you will not define the word, stop using it as a conviction. You rewrote “define your charge or drop it” into “obey me or I win,” because the real version has no answer. The meme is the wrong tantrum. Anakin wanted a rank he had not earned. I asked you to read the statute you are sentencing me under. You still have not said what woke is.
Really isn’t very convincing when you then immediately demand:
You still have not said what woke is
I don’t really know how else to explain the basic concept that I don’t, y’know, have to do what you say. Maybe “I’m not playing your game” or “I refuse to dignify your abhorrent behavior by giving in to your demands” or maybe even something really clear like “I don’t really know how else to explain the basic concept that I don’t, y’know, have to do what you say.”
Seriously, this is getting to be a little revelatory.
You keep trying to make this into a formal debate, and not seeming to understand I’m doing paradox of tolerance here…
Still can’t define woke
That’s your requirement, not mine - I don’t actually have to engage with you in the way you want, even if you want me to do it really really hard.
Seriously this isn’t going to become a structured debate, I don’t reward hate.
The paradox of tolerance is a rule about conduct, not a license to skip the definition. Popper’s limit is on people who would end debate by force. Disagreeing with an ideology is not that, and calling it hate does not make it that. “I don’t reward hate” is the verdict again, written before the argument was read. You still have not said what woke is. You have only said you will not answer, and then treated the refusal as proof you were right. That is not tolerance. That is a closed room.
Once again: just because you’re demanding that I do something doesn’t mean I have to do it. I know it’s worryingly hard to accept, but just because you want something doesn’t mean other people have to give it to you.
You don’t have to define it. You also don’t get to call the definition wrong, the argument debunked, or the criticism hate, while refusing to say what the word means. “I don’t have to” is not an answer. It is the refusal, said out loud. A word you will not define cannot convict anyone.
That refusal is the system. The charge works only if the word stays undefined. Define woke and it can be tested, and a tested charge can fail. Leave it undefined and it can be applied to anyone, and the denial is taken as proof. That is why you will not say what it means. A heresy with no definition cannot be answered, only confessed to. “I don’t have to” is not a rebuttal. It is the clergy declining to show the accused the statute.
“No, you’re not allowed to just not do what I want! You have to do what I want, and if you don’t that means I’m right!”
That is not the demand. The demand was: if you will not define the word, stop using it as a conviction. You rewrote “define your charge or drop it” into “obey me or I win,” because the real version has no answer. The meme is the wrong tantrum. Anakin wanted a rank he had not earned. I asked you to read the statute you are sentencing me under. You still have not said what woke is.
Really isn’t very convincing when you then immediately demand:
I don’t really know how else to explain the basic concept that I don’t, y’know, have to do what you say. Maybe “I’m not playing your game” or “I refuse to dignify your abhorrent behavior by giving in to your demands” or maybe even something really clear like “I don’t really know how else to explain the basic concept that I don’t, y’know, have to do what you say.”
Seriously, this is getting to be a little revelatory.