• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 25th, 2023

help-circle


  • I don’t like your two options lmao.

    The answer is somewhere in the middle. I’m higher on Ridder than I am Smith but really there isn’t a good solution to either.

    There are so many coaching positions opening up, and so many qb needy teams that I just wonder how we upgrade at either. I really don’t love AS but who could we realistically get to replace him? Who do we replace Ridder with? This is the team Arthur and Terry built. It looks like we’ll stumble into a division win this year. I expect improvement to that as a fan next year.

    If the team ends with 9+ wins and a playoff game, I think AS and Ridder get one more year with the draft being used exclusively for D-Line and a WR2. Then we can see where we are.

    We keep winning too many games for a drafted QB and no free agent ones are worth the money. If we lose out from this point or something like that, then maybe things open back up but currently Williams, Maye, Daniels and even Penix are outside of our draft position. If Arizona moves off Kyler maybe we bite at that, but I don’t love that either. I certainly don’t think a 35 Kirk Cousins off an achilles moves the needle.




  • Our offense is not performing perfectly fine for the circumstances. If we have great talent all over the offense except QB then how are we moving the ball well yardage wise with an absolute inability to score close where your QB matters less.

    We also don’t have a trash defense. We spent a crazy amount of money on them last year and until the wheels started falling off the past couple of weeks we’ve been Top 10. We’re also playing the easiest schedule with the most amount of brand new QBs I’ve ever seen. Arthur Smith is also almost completely 100% hands off with the defense. I’ve never even heard him praise the defense at all this season, which is strange considering they’re the reason we won 3 of our 4 wins.

    No one is complaining about Jonnu’s production in the passing game. London and Pitts usage are both fine. We’re complaining about Jonnu’s Smith’s usage in the redzone on trick plays and with Bijan’s usage in total but espically in the redzone.

    It is absolutely malpractice to save your 21 rookie RB with the division being so weak. The Falcons could very feasibly be 6-3 this year and in total control of our division and frankly, we should be. If we “weren’t ready to compete yet” then drafting a RB at 8 to replace your young 1000 yard rusher is the firable offense. Either way you slice it he’s fucking it up.

    Atlanta was suppose to compete this year. I’m not drinking so much copium to think we were competitive in the playoffs necessarily, but we absolutely should be competing for NFC South title and the fact that we’re going 7-10 AGAIN is frustrating and a lot of that falls on Arthur Smith.