I prefer whatever sounds best and that can be either vinyl or hires.
But, as people have mentioned, it’ll all depend on how and for which format it’s mastered / cut.
I’m all about music recorded pre-1985ish first pressings and “audiophile” AAA vinyl cuts: there is little chance they’re mastering for the loudness wars.
After ‘85, I’ll check on feedback for any pressings as, again, it’s avoiding the loudness wars. But it is not a given it’ll sound any good because, at that point, vinyl is a second thought.
Another factor: age demographic. As listening is so subjective, I think an older cohort is going to prefer vinyl as that’s through what they created a relationship to music. The older gens are going to be able to afford systems they can show off. Younger people are, imo, by and large fine with digital and streaming.
Autechres NTS in HiRes puts a system through its paces.